Is renting vs owning in retirement cheaper once property tax, insurance and repairs are counted?
Say you own a paid-off house worth about $320,000. Property tax runs $4,200 a year, homeowners insurance $2,300, and repairs eat another few thousand when the roof, furnace or water heater goes. A one-bedroom apartment nearby rents for $1,600 a month. Selling would free up cash, but you would give up the one cost that does not rise every year. You are on a fixed income and wonder whether renting vs owning in retirement really saves money once you count everything. What numbers decide it, and what are the traps?
1 reply
-
💡 BudgetSeniors team Team 4 months ago For a paid-off house, owning usually wins on monthly cash, but the answer flips more easily than most people expect once you count what the sale proceeds could earn and how fast rent rises. Renting vs owning in retirement comes down to four numbers you can find this week: your yearly property tax, insurance, upkeep, and the rent you'd really pay. The example below shows the method. Swap in your own figures, and treat this as general information, not tax or financial advice.
The monthly cash math for a paid-off home
Say you own a house worth $320,000 outright. Property tax is $4,200 a year and homeowners insurance is $2,300. You set aside $3,500 a year for repairs, because roofs, water heaters and furnaces don't fail on a schedule. That's $10,000 a year, or about $833 a month, before utilities. Utilities are similar in an apartment, so leave them out of both sides.
Now say a decent one-bedroom near you rents for $1,600 a month, which is $19,200 a year, plus $200 a year for renter's insurance. On cash alone, owning costs about $9,400 a year less. That's $783 a month.
For a sense of scale, Harvard's Joint Center for Housing Studies, using 2021 American Community Survey data, reported median monthly housing costs for households 65 and older of $520 for owners without a mortgage, $940 for renters, and $1,470 for owners with a mortgage. Those are survey medians from 2021, not a budget for a new roof, and prices are higher now. The pattern still holds: the paid-off owner is the cheapest, and the owner with a mortgage is the most expensive.
AdvertisementRenting vs owning in retirement: what the sale money does
Selling changes the picture because the $320,000 stops being a house and becomes cash. Say selling costs run 6%, about $19,200, leaving $300,800. If that money earned 4% a year, it would produce about $12,000. Subtract that from the renter's $19,400 and your net cost of renting is roughly $7,400 a year, less than the $10,000 owning costs.
Run it the other way. Renting beats owning only when the money earns more than about 3.1% a year, since $9,400 divided by $300,800 is 3.1%. Below that, owning wins. Interest is taxable too, so the break-even is a bit higher after tax.
Then add the part that tilts the other direction: rent doesn't stay put. Say your $1,600 rent rises 4% a year. After ten years it would be about $2,368 a month. Property tax and insurance rise too, but your tax may be frozen or reduced if your area has senior relief, and a home you own doesn't suddenly raise your housing payment because a new landlord bought the building. Your savings, meanwhile, get drawn down to pay rent that climbs.
Harvard's housing center found that in 2021 about 56% of older renter households, more than 4 million, were cost burdened (spending over 30% of income on housing) compared with 26% of older homeowners. Among older renters earning under $25,000, 73% were cost burdened. The same report found median net wealth for older homeowners was $499,000 in 2022 against $10,100 for older renters, with median home equity of $250,000. Owners also have a financial cushion renters often lack. It also noted that property insurance fees are rising with more frequent and costly hazards, and that 41% of homeowners aged 65 to 79 had a mortgage in 2022.
Those numbers show averages, not your case. They do tell you something useful: renting is rarely a cost-saving move for someone with a low income and few savings, because rent has no end date. An owner with no mortgage gets a housing cost that's mostly predictable.
The IRS explains that if you sell your main home, you may exclude up to $250,000 of gain from income, or up to $500,000 if you file a joint return, when you meet the ownership and use tests: you owned and lived in the home for at least two of the five years before the sale. If your gain is larger than that, the rules get more detailed, so ask a tax preparer or call a free tax help site such as AARP Foundation Tax-Aide or the IRS Volunteer Income Tax Assistance (VITA) program before listing.
AdvertisementCheaper ways to stay put
Before you sell, check three things that cut the owner side of the ledger:
- Property tax relief. Many states and counties give seniors an exemption, a freeze or a deferral. Texas is one example: the state comptroller says school districts must give homeowners 65 or older, or disabled, an additional $60,000 homestead exemption, and local taxing units may add their own. Rules vary widely, so call your county assessor or appraisal district and ask what applies to you and how to apply. Be wary of any company that charges a fee to file the paperwork for you, since the county office can tell you how to apply directly.
- Insurance shopping. Ask for quotes from at least three insurers or an independent agent, and ask about deductible choices. A higher deductible cuts the premium only if you actually have cash set aside to cover it.
- A repair reserve. If you can't set aside $3,500 a year, that's a sign the house may become a burden. Ask your Area Agency on Aging, found through the Eldercare Locator at 1-800-677-1116, about repair and home-modification programs.
If you do move, compare the whole cost, not just rent. Add moving costs, the deposit, and fees for parking, pets or utilities. Ask about the lease: how long, how much it can rise, and whether the building has senior units. A one-year lease with an unlimited increase at renewal is different from a longer term with a cap.
When owning stops making sense
Owning loses its edge in a few cases. One is a house that needs a roof, furnace and windows in the next few years, costing more than you could ever save. Another is an older person who can no longer manage stairs or yard work, so you'd be paying for help on top of the bills. A third is a mortgage payment that eats most of your income: the Harvard report notes homeowners with mortgages have much higher costs than those who own outright. In any of those, selling and renting, or moving to a senior community with services, might leave you with lower and steadier costs, and the equity can fund years of rent.
Whatever you do, avoid deciding because a relative, a real estate agent or an ad says "downsizing is smart." Pick the plan that survives a bad year: a rent hike, a major repair, or care costs. Build a one-page table with two columns, "stay" and "sell and rent," then fill in yearly tax, insurance, repairs, rent, expected earnings on proceeds, and selling costs. Compare totals over ten years, with rent rising and returns lower than you'd like. If renting still wins under cautious assumptions, it's a reasonable move; if it only wins when everything goes right, stay.
Key sources: Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies; IRS; Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts