My homeowners insurance increase is $600 a year on a fixed income. What can I do?
Suppose the renewal notice says your premium jumps from $2,400 to $3,000 a year, which is $50 a month more out of a $1,900 Social Security check. The house is paid off, you have not filed a claim in years, and the letter doesn’t say why. You wonder whether to raise the deductible, switch companies, drop coverage you might not need, or ask for discounts. What should you ask the insurer, how do deductible choices change the math, and what is a safe way to compare quotes without leaving the house underinsured?
1 reply
-
💡 BudgetSeniors team Team 6 days ago When a homeowners insurance increase lands in the mailbox, the first move isn't to pay it or cancel. It's to call the company and ask exactly why it went up, then get quotes from at least two other insurers before the renewal date. On a fixed income, a jump from $2,400 to $3,000 a year is $50 a month you didn't plan on, and there are several legitimate ways to claw some of it back without leaving the house exposed. This is how to go about it, in order.
Step one: find out why your homeowners insurance increase happened
Texas regulators put it plainly in their consumer advice: if your bill is rising, ask your company to explain the increase and whether you're getting every discount you qualify for. Insurers raise rates for reasons that have nothing to do with you personally, like claims in your region, or reasons that do, like a claim you filed or a change in your credit information. You have a right to ask which it is.
Questions to ask the agent or the company's customer service line:
- Is this a rate increase across my area, or specific to my policy?
- Did my coverage amount change? Ask how the company arrived at the cost to rebuild my home.
- Am I getting every discount? Ask by name: monitored burglar or fire alarm, being with the same company for other policies, and no claims in recent years. The Texas Department of Insurance lists those three.
- Does my age, retirement or membership in a group qualify me for anything? Minnesota's insurance regulator notes that discounts and group rates are sometimes available to seniors or members of a professional or business organization, and that it varies by company.
AdvertisementJot down each answer, plus the name of whoever gave it and the date of the call.
Step two: look at the deductible, but do the math
A higher deductible lowers your premium. State insurance regulators all say the same. The tradeoff is that you pay more out of your own pocket if there's a claim, and the Texas department asks the right question: how much could you afford to pay if your home were damaged?
Minnesota's regulator gives a rough idea of the size of the savings: doubling a deductible from a standard $250 can often reduce rates about 12 percent, and raising it to $2,500 can often save about 30 percent. Treat that as a rule of thumb, since your own quotes will differ, but it shows the shape of the trade.
Try it with your numbers. If your premium is $3,000 and a $2,500 deductible saves 30 percent, you'd save $900 a year. The extra amount you'd bear if you filed a claim, compared with a $250 deductible, is $2,250. Divide the one by the other and you get 2.5, so you'd come out ahead if you go about two and a half years without a claim. That is a fine bet if you have $2,500 in a savings account set aside for it, and a poor one if you'd have to put a repair on a credit card.
So a higher deductible only makes sense with an emergency fund behind it. If you don't have one, raise it more modestly, say to $1,000, and ask for quotes at several levels so you can see the actual savings.
Step three: shop, and compare like with like
Texas regulators tell homeowners to shop around because companies charge different rates, and your own company may have raised yours. To compare quotes fairly, ask each company for the same things:
- The same coverage amounts for the house, other structures and belongings.
- The same deductibles, including any separate deductible for wind or hail, which some policies have. Ask whether it's a flat dollar amount or a percentage of the home's value.
- Whether the policy pays the cost to replace damaged items, or only their depreciated value. Replacement-cost policies usually protect more and cost more, so a cheaper quote may be paying you less when you need it.
- What's excluded. Floods, for example, are generally not covered by a standard homeowners policy. FEMA's FloodSmart site says most homeowners insurance does not cover flood damage and points people to the National Flood Insurance Program for a separate policy. If you live near water or in a low spot, ask an agent about it, because that's a separate cost, not part of the homeowners bill.
AdvertisementCheck each company's complaint record before you buy. Your state insurance department will tell you how. Texas, for example, runs a help line at 800-252-3439 for that.
Step four: check the things that affect your rate
- Credit information. New York's regulator says insurers that use credit information must give you notice, and if you find an error in your credit report you have the right to get it corrected and tell your insurer, which may entitle you to a refund and a lower premium. It also says that on request an insurer must review your credit information at least once every three years, and that if it has improved, the company must make any necessary adjustments. Other states have their own rules, so ask yours.
- Safety features. Ask whether a monitored alarm or smoke detectors would cut your rate before you buy one. Don't spend money on a gadget without getting the discount in writing first.
- Home improvements that reduce risk. In September 2026 the Texas Department of Insurance issued a bulletin pushing insurers to give premium discounts to homeowners who make their homes more resistant to storm and wildfire damage, such as roofs that meet an industry FORTIFIED standard. Ask your own state's insurance department whether it has anything similar, since details vary widely, and get any discount quoted in writing before paying for work.
- Claims history. Not filing claims for three straight years is a discount in Texas. Think twice before filing a small claim, though not at the cost of a repair that gets worse. Ask your agent how a claim would affect your renewal.
If you still have a mortgage, your lender may pay your insurance from an escrow account, so the increase shows up as a higher monthly payment after an annual escrow review. The same advice applies. Shop for a new policy, send the lender proof of coverage, and ask it to update the escrow. If you own your house outright, you're writing the check yourself, so you have more freedom to choose.
If no one will insure you at a price you can afford
That can happen, especially in areas with wildfire, hurricane or hail risk. There is no single national rule, so call your state department of insurance and ask what the options are if you're nonrenewed or can't find coverage. Some states run an insurer of last resort or a similar plan, but whether yours does, and what it costs and covers, is a question for the department. Ask the department for the exact notice period an insurer must give before it cancels or doesn't renew, and for help if you think it was done improperly.
Never let the policy lapse. A house without coverage is a risk to your whole nest egg, and loans secured by the house usually require it. With a reverse mortgage, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau says you must keep paying homeowners insurance and property taxes.
A few other ways to ease the bill:
- Ask your Area Agency on Aging about property tax relief and repair programs. Cutting another bill can make room for the insurance increase. If you need to find that office, the Eldercare Locator at 1-800-677-1116 can match you to it.
- Ask about paying in installments instead of one lump sum, if the company allows it, and whether it adds a fee.
- Don't buy extras you don't need, but don't cut dwelling coverage below what it would cost to rebuild just to save a few dollars.
Here is a short script for the phone call.
"My premium went up from $2,400 to $3,000. Can you tell me why? Which discounts am I getting? What would it cost with a $1,000 deductible and a $2,500 deductible? And what's the cost of replacing my home that you're using for the coverage amount?"
Then call two other companies and ask for the same numbers. This is general information, not insurance advice for your specific policy, so have the agent put the coverage terms in writing before you decide.
Key sources: Texas Department of Insurance; Minnesota Department of Commerce; New York DFS; FEMA