Skip to content
🏠 Housing

Is downsizing in retirement worth it if I’d net about $90,000 after selling?

Asked by BudgetSeniors team · 1 month ago

Picture a retiree living on about $1,900 a month from Social Security in a paid-off house that would sell for roughly $320,000. A $200,000 condo is available in cash, but it comes with a $350 monthly association fee. The house costs money to keep up, though the move means selling costs, moving costs and leaving a neighborhood. The question is how downsizing in retirement actually adds up: what is left after the sale, what each home costs per year, what tax applies to the profit, and whether the cash left over helps or creates new problems with benefits and taxes.

1 reply

  1. BudgetSeniors team Team 1 month ago

    Before you list the house, put two columns on one sheet of paper: what you would net from the sale, and what the new place costs you every month, all in. For most people thinking about downsizing in retirement, the answer isn't decided by the sale price. It comes down to the gap between the old house's yearly costs and the new place's yearly costs, plus the one-time bill for getting from one to the other. Below is a way to work that out with your own figures.

    Downsizing in retirement: start with what you'd really walk away with

    Real estate listings talk about the sale price. You live on the net. Start there and subtract the costs of selling: the agent's commission, any advertising, legal fees, and any repairs you agree to make for the buyer. The IRS lists commissions, advertising and legal fees as selling expenses in its guide to selling your home, and they come off the price when you figure your gain.

    Here is how it can run with round numbers; swap in your own. Say the house sells for $320,000, and you assume 8 percent in total selling costs, which is $25,600. After paying off any remaining mortgage, you'd have $294,400. Now suppose you buy a condo for $200,000 in cash. That leaves $94,400, and you still have moving costs, a deposit for utilities, and probably a few furniture purchases. If those total $4,000, you're at $90,400.

    Advertisement

    The 8 percent figure is an assumption, not a rule. Ask two or three agents for their fee in writing before you do anything else, and ask what closing costs the seller usually pays in your area.

    Now compare the yearly cost of each home

    This is the step most people skip. List what the current house costs per year: property tax, homeowners insurance, utilities, repairs, lawn or snow help. Then list the same for the new place, including any monthly association fee and its own insurance and tax.

    Say the house costs $3,600 in property tax, $1,800 in insurance, and you set aside $3,000 a year for repairs, for $8,400 before utilities. The condo has $350 a month in association fees, which is $4,200, plus $1,200 in property tax and $400 in insurance for the contents, for $5,800. The yearly difference is $2,600, or about $217 a month. That is real money on $1,900 a month, but it isn't life-changing, and it can disappear if the association raises its fee or levies a special assessment for a roof or elevator. Ask for the association's budget and its reserve fund before you commit.

    The $90,400 in the example is what funds your budget, and the way to think about it is a slow income stream, not a windfall. If it sat in an insured savings account earning 3 percent, that would be about $2,712 a year before tax. Check what rates are actually being paid when you decide. Interest counts as taxable income, and enough of it can push part of your Social Security into the taxable column. IRS Publication 915 sets the starting line: if half your benefits plus your other income stay under $25,000 (single) or $32,000 (married filing jointly), none of the benefit is taxed.

    Keep the money in accounts covered by federal deposit insurance, which protects up to $250,000 at each insured bank. Be wary of anyone who appears right after a sale offering a product that promises more. The sale of a house is a well-known time for sales pitches.

    The tax rule that usually protects you

    Advertisement

    If you sell your main home at a gain, the IRS lets you exclude up to $250,000 of the gain from income, or $500,000 if you file jointly. To qualify you generally must have owned the home and lived in it for at least two of the last five years. In the example above, the gain is the price minus selling costs minus your basis. If you bought for $140,000 and spent $20,000 on improvements, your basis is $160,000, so the gain is $320,000 minus $25,600 minus $160,000, which is $134,400. That's well under the single-filer exclusion, so none of it would be taxed.

    Some details worth knowing:

    • Keep records of improvements such as a new roof, a bathroom remodel or an addition. They raise your basis and reduce your gain.
    • If you become unable to care for yourself and move to a licensed care facility, time there can count toward the two-year residence test, as long as you lived in the home at least 12 months of the previous five years.
    • If your spouse died and you haven't remarried, you may qualify for the $500,000 exclusion if you sell within two years of the death and meet the other conditions in the IRS rules.
    • If you inherited the home, or received it from a spouse, your basis may be different from what you paid. Don't guess. Read IRS Publication 523 or ask a tax preparer.

    The costs people forget

    • Overlap: if you buy before you sell, you pay two sets of carrying costs for a while. Don't borrow against the old house to buy the new one if you can avoid it.
    • Moving and sorting. Downsizing means deciding what to do with forty years of belongings. Budget time and some money for it.
    • Distance from family, doctors and your church or club. A cheaper town 90 minutes away can cost you in gas, isolation and unfamiliar doctors.
    • Rent versus buy: if you plan to rent, work out what happens when the landlord raises the rent. A paid-off house has a fixed cost; rent doesn't.
    • Medicare and benefits: Medicare.gov says the Part B premium can be higher depending on your income, so ask whether a taxable gain could affect yours. Sale proceeds sitting in the bank can also affect programs that count savings. Medicare.gov lists a 2026 savings cap of $9,950 for one person in a Medicare Savings Program, and SNAP's countable-asset limit is $4,750 for a household with a member 60 or older. If you receive help from either, ask the agency before you close.

    Cheaper alternatives to selling

    Moving isn't the only way to cut housing costs. Weatherization help, a state or local property tax break for seniors, or a Section 504 repair grant for very-low-income rural homeowners 62 and older can all lower the cost of staying. The CFPB lists downsizing alongside waiting, a home equity loan, refinancing and lowering expenses as options to compare, and says moving to a more affordable home may be the best way to reduce your overall expenses for some people. Phone the Eldercare Locator, 1-800-677-1116, and ask who runs aging services in your county; that office knows which of these exist locally.

    Before you call an agent, run through this checklist.

    • Write down your current housing cost per year, line by line.
    • Get a rough price range from a couple of agents, and their commissions in writing.
    • Price three places you'd actually consider and add up their yearly costs.
    • Estimate your gain, and read the IRS rules, or ask a free tax volunteer.
    • Decide what the leftover cash is for, and where it will be safe.

    If the numbers show the new place costing about the same as the old one, with a smaller cash cushion, then staying and fixing what needs fixing may be the better deal. If the yearly gap is large and the cash is meaningful, selling can make your fixed income stretch farther. This is general information, not tax or financial advice, so run your own figures past a tax preparer before you sign.

    Key sources: IRS; Consumer Financial Protection Bureau; FDIC

Add your reply

Your email is never shown. Be kind — someone may be worried about money. Never post account, Social Security or Medicare numbers.