The Cheapest Home Insurance for Seniors

Key Takeaways: Your Quick-Reference Guide 💡

• What’s the average cost of home insurance nationally? The average homeowners insurance cost nationwide is $2,543 a year for $300,000 in dwelling coverage.

• Which company is cheapest for seniors? AIG is the cheapest provider nationally, with average rates around $91 per month for $250K in dwelling coverage.

• Can bundling really save money? Yes, seniors can save up to 25% by combining home and auto policies with one insurer.

• Do seniors get special discounts? Allstate provides a 20% discount for retired homeowners over 55.

• Which states have the cheapest home insurance? Hawaii is the cheapest state for home insurance at only $659 a year.

• Where is home insurance most expensive? Florida homeowners pay an average of $10,240 per year, 189% above the national average.

🏆 Yes, Your Age Can Actually Work in Your Favor: Senior-Specific Discounts Explained

Contrary to what many seniors believe, being older doesn’t automatically increase your home insurance premiums. In fact, insurance companies often view retirees as lower-risk policyholders because they’re home more often, which reduces the likelihood of undetected burglaries, fires, or water damage going unnoticed.

In fact, many seniors might even find themselves paying less for home insurance. This can be due to discounts offered by insurers for things like having a claims-free history, bundling home and auto insurance, or installing safety features in the home. Additionally, some insurance companies offer specific discounts for retirees, recognizing that being home more often can lower the risk of incidents like burglary or fire going unnoticed.

Many insurers also offer opportunities to save on your homeowners insurance as a senior. Common home insurance discounts that could benefit you include: Loyalty discount if you bundle your policies or have maintained the same coverage with the same insurer for several years. Retiree discount that lets you save on homeowners insurance in your golden years.

Discount Type	Typical Savings	How to Qualify	💡 Senior Advantage
Retiree/Senior discount	10-20%	Be 55+ or retired	Being home more reduces risk 🏠
Claims-free discount	5-20%	No claims for 3-5 years	Long homeownership history helps ✅
Loyalty discount	5-10%	Stay with same insurer 5+ years	Seniors often have longer tenure 🎯
Bundling discount	10-25%	Combine home and auto	Consolidate all policies under one roof 📦
Paid-in-full discount	5-10%	Pay annual premium upfront	Retirees often prefer this approach 💵

💡 Expert Insight: The Hartford offers exclusive benefits and discounts just for AARP members. In fact, you can save nearly $1,000 when you bundle your home and car insurance.

💰 The Real Numbers: What Home Insurance Actually Costs by State

Location dramatically impacts what you’ll pay, sometimes by thousands of dollars annually. For those on fixed incomes, it’s hard to overstate the importance of keeping a tight rein on costs. With many retirees on tight budgets and having little ability to generate other income, each expense is a trade-off with something else that might be just as important.

The cheapest states for home insurance share common characteristics: lower exposure to catastrophic weather, reduced crime rates, and stable housing markets.

The average home insurance cost by state varies, with the nationwide average coming in at $2,601 a year. The cheapest state for home insurance is Hawaii at $613 a year, and the most expensive state is Oklahoma at $5,858 a year.

Discover T-Mobile Senior Internet Plan

State Category	Examples	Average Annual Cost	💡 Why Prices Differ
Most affordable	Hawaii, Vermont, New Hampshire	$600-$900	Lower disaster risk, mild climates 🌴
Below average	Oregon, Utah, Idaho	$1,000-$1,800	Moderate weather, competitive markets ⛰️
National average	Pennsylvania, Michigan	$2,400-$2,800	Typical risk profile 📊
Above average	Colorado, Texas, Louisiana	$3,500-$6,200	Tornado alley, hurricanes, wildfires 🌪️
Most expensive	Florida, Oklahoma, Nebraska	$5,800-$10,200	Extreme weather, high rebuild costs 💸

For households with a mortgage, Florida ($2,273) had the highest median annual insurance costs in 2023, followed by Louisiana ($2,140) and Oklahoma ($2,041).

💡 Pro Tip: If you’re considering relocating in retirement, home insurance costs should factor heavily into your decision. Louisiana was ranked the worst state to retire in Bankrate’s Best and Worst States to Retire Study. A key factor in this ranking is that it’s the second-most expensive state for home insurance.

🏢 The Companies That Actually Deliver Low Rates for Seniors

Not all insurers treat seniors equally. Some have built their entire business model around serving older Americans, while others simply add senior discounts as an afterthought.

AIG Insurance is the cheapest home insurance provider for seniors, offering a policy with $250K in dwelling coverage and a $1,000 deductible at an average of $91 a month. This is $201 cheaper than the average cost for seniors.

Allstate, State Farm, and Travelers are some of the cheapest home insurance companies for seniors.

Company	Average Monthly Cost	Key Senior Benefits	💡 Best For
AIG Insurance	$91/month	Lowest national rates	Budget-conscious seniors 💵
Amica	$119/month	High customer satisfaction	Quality-focused retirees ⭐
AAA	Varies by region	Membership benefits	AAA members already enrolled 🚗
The Hartford/AARP	Competitive	Exclusive AARP discounts	AARP members seeking bundling 🎯
State Farm	Above average	Strong agent network	Seniors wanting local support 🤝
USAA	$Excellent rates	Military-exclusive	Veterans and military families 🎖️
Travelers	$Higher base rates	Older home expertise	Seniors in historic properties 🏛️

Contact Information for Top Senior-Focused Insurers:

Company	Phone Number	Special Notes
The Hartford (AARP Program)	877-422-2345	AARP membership required
USAA	800-531-8722	Military/veteran families only
State Farm	800-782-8332	Local agent network
Allstate	800-255-7828	25% bundling discount
Progressive	866-749-7436	Online quote tools
Travelers	800-842-5075	Historic home specialists

💡 Expert Insight: The Hartford offer discounts to senior homeowners. A unique discount they offer is “retiree credits” for policyholders who work less than 24 hours a week.

📦 Bundling Is Your Secret Weapon: The Math Behind Multi-Policy Savings

If you’re still paying separate companies for home and auto insurance, you’re almost certainly overpaying. Getting a home and auto insurance bundle is typically cheaper than buying separate policies. An unbundled auto insurance policy costs an average of $925 per year, while a home insurance plan costs an average of $1,718 per year. That’s a total of $2,643 per year. The average total cost of a bundled home and auto insurance policy is $2,071 per year.

That’s a savings of approximately $572 annually just for consolidating your policies.

Based on average discount percentages, State Farm is MoneyGeek’s top pick for cheap home and auto insurance quotes for seniors. The company has the highest average discount at 25%.

Discover Sunrise Senior Living Contact Number

Insurer	Average Bundle Savings	Bundle Discount %	💡 Additional Perks
State Farm	Highest tier	25%	Strong local agent support 🤝
Allstate	$601 annually	Up to 25%	Accident forgiveness available ✅
Travelers	$601 annually	Significant	OpenHouse home history reports 📋
The Hartford	$963 annually	22% home / 6% auto	AARP exclusive benefits 🎯
Progressive	Varies	Multi-policy discount	One deductible for combined claims 💰
Nationwide	$511 annually	Competitive	Strong claims handling reputation ⭐

Combining home and auto insurance policies can be a smart move for seniors looking for ways to save money. Many insurance providers offer multi-policy discounts, which lower overall premiums. Additionally, bundling policies can simplify insurance policy management.

💡 Pro Tip: Discount options differ depending on the insurance company. Shopping around with multiple insurers is the best way to find a set of discounts that aligns with your situation.

🏠 Own an Older Home? What You Must Know About HO-8 Policies

Many seniors have owned their homes for decades, which means those properties may now be 40 years old or more. This creates unique insurance challenges that can significantly impact both coverage and cost.

Many of the unique qualities in older homes also make them riskier to insure, which can lead to a higher rate and the need for specialized coverage.

An HO-8 policy, also called a modified coverage form, is a type of homeowners insurance that is primarily designed for older homes or historic residences that otherwise wouldn’t qualify for coverage under a standard home insurance policy.

This kind of policy is usually required with homes that are over 40 years old, registered as landmarks, historically significant or built using materials or techniques that are difficult to replace or replicate.

Standard HO-3 Policy	HO-8 Policy (Older Homes)	💡 Key Difference
Open-peril coverage	Named-peril only	HO-8 covers fewer damage types ⚠️
Replacement cost payout	Actual cash value (depreciation)	HO-8 pays less on claims 💸
Modern home requirements	Accepts outdated systems	HO-8 doesn’t require upgrades ✅
Four-point inspection often required	No inspection typically needed	Easier qualification for older homes 📋
Higher premiums sometimes	May cost less	Trade-off is reduced coverage 🔄

HO-8 policies cover fewer perils and include lower dwelling coverage limits but may cost less. Insurers may require you to purchase an HO-8 policy if they determine that it would cost more to rebuild your home than it’s currently worth.

What makes older homes riskier to insure:

Depending on the age and type of electrical system, your property may not be eligible for coverage. Older electrical systems may need to be professionally decommissioned, and a new system installed.

Home Feature	Concern for Insurers	Potential Solution	💡 Impact on Premiums
Original wiring (knob-and-tube)	Fire hazard	Professional rewiring	Major reduction after update ⚡
Older plumbing (galvanized pipes)	Leak and burst risk	Pipe replacement	Moderate savings 🚰
Original roof (20+ years)	Weather damage vulnerability	Roof replacement	Significant discount possible 🏚️
Wood-burning stove/fireplace	Fire risk	Proper inspection/certification	Small reduction 🔥

💡 Expert Insight: Updates to your older home, such as a new roof, can better safeguard your property against damage from perils and potentially lower your home insurance rate.

🛡️ Hidden Discounts Most Seniors Never Think to Ask About

Beyond the obvious senior and bundling discounts, numerous savings opportunities exist that agents rarely mention unless specifically asked.

Discover What Insurance Covers Hearing Aids for Seniors?

Some insurers offer a discount if you also buy your auto insurance from them or if you disaster-proof your home (for example, add storm shutters), update the home’s electrical or plumbing systems, get a new roof or add home security devices (for example, a burglar alarm).

Many insurers offer a discount if you have a burglar alarm, deadbolts on doors or other security devices for windows.

Discount Category	Specific Examples	Typical Savings	💡 Implementation Tips
Protective devices	Smoke detectors, fire extinguishers, sprinklers	2-15%	Document all safety features 🚨
Security systems	Burglar alarms, smart locks, cameras	5-20%	Monitored systems save more 📹
Home improvements	New roof, updated wiring, modern plumbing	5-25%	Provide documentation of upgrades 🔧
Weather protection	Storm shutters, hurricane-resistant windows	Varies by state	Required in some coastal areas 🌊
Payment methods	Autopay, paid-in-full, paperless	3-10%	Stack multiple payment discounts 💳
Membership affiliations	AARP, AAA, alumni associations	5-15%	Check all memberships you hold 🎫

You should also check with your insurance company to see if they offer premium discounts for the use of dead-bolt locks, smoke alarms, fire extinguishers, sprinkler systems and security systems. Insurers in some states are required to offer premium discounts if a policyholder has installed hurricane/storm shutters and/or hurricane-resistant laminated glass windows and doors.

💡 Pro Tip: Create a comprehensive list of every safety and security feature in your home before requesting quotes. Many seniors don’t realize their existing smoke detectors, deadbolts, and fire extinguishers qualify for discounts.

📊 Deductible Strategy: How Much Risk Should You Take On?

Choosing the right deductible represents one of the most powerful cost-control levers available to seniors.

A higher deductible will mean a lower rate. Raising your deductible from $1,000 to $2,500 can save you about 12% a year on average.

However, this strategy requires careful consideration of your emergency fund and ability to pay out-of-pocket costs if you need to file a claim.

Deductible Amount	Annual Premium Impact	Best For	💡 Financial Consideration
$500	Highest premiums	Seniors with limited savings	Easy to pay if claim needed 💰
$1,000	Standard premiums	Most homeowners	Balance of cost and coverage ⚖️
$1,500	Moderate savings	Seniors with emergency fund	Meaningful discount available 📉
$2,500	~12% savings	Those with substantial savings	Requires cash reserves ready 🏦
$5,000+	Maximum savings	Wealthy homeowners only	High out-of-pocket risk ⚠️

A deductible is the amount you must pay out-of-pocket on a claim before the policy pays the loss. For example, assume you have a $1,000 deductible and the total claim is $5,000. You’d pay $1,000 and collect $4,000 from the insurer.

💡 Expert Insight: Make sure you choose the coverage you need with a deductible you can afford if you experience a loss. Never choose a deductible higher than your available emergency savings.

⚖️ Your Rights as a Consumer: Filing Complaints and Getting Help

When insurance companies deny claims unfairly or raise rates without justification, seniors have powerful recourse through state regulators.

If you’re dissatisfied with the actions of your insurance company or insurance agent, you can file a complaint with your state department of insurance. Delays, denials, and unsatisfactory settlements are among some of the most common reasons for consumers to file complaints.

The NAIC compiles closed, confirmed complaint information about insurance carriers from state insurance departments. That information is available to state insurance regulators and consumers.

Resource	Contact Method	What They Handle	💡 When to Use
Your State Insurance Dept	Find at naic.org	Policy disputes, rate complaints	First line of defense 📋
NAIC Consumer Services	naic.org/consumer	Company research, complaint database	Before buying any policy 🔍
State Attorney General	Varies by state	Consumer fraud, deceptive practices	If fraud suspected ⚖️
Better Business Bureau	bbb.org	Company ratings, dispute resolution	For service complaints 📊

State Insurance Department Contact Examples:

State	Phone	Website Focus
California	Insurance.ca.gov	Consumer complaint portal
Texas	800-252-3439	Help line available M-F
Florida	877-693-5236	Rate comparison tools
New York	800-342-3736	Senior-focused resources

Compare insurance companies. Shop around to find the best price and coverage for you, including discounts.

💡 Pro Tip: Before purchasing any policy, use the NAIC Consumer Insurance Search to check the company’s complaint history and financial strength ratings.

📝 The Coverage Every Senior Actually Needs

Understanding what protection you truly require prevents both overpaying for unnecessary coverage and being dangerously underinsured.

For many consumers, their home is their most valuable asset, making homeowners insurance essential. It protects both the structure and personal belongings, provides liability coverage for injuries or damages on the property, and often serves as the primary source of rebuilding funds after a total loss.

Coverage Type	What It Protects	Senior Considerations	💡 Recommendation
Dwelling (Coverage A)	Home structure, attached features	Ensure adequate rebuild coverage	Insure at 100% replacement cost 🏠
Other Structures (B)	Detached garages, sheds, fences	May be minimal for smaller properties	10% of dwelling coverage standard 🏚️
Personal Property (C)	Furniture, electronics, clothing	Consider downsizing impact	Inventory valuables, adjust coverage 📦
Loss of Use (D)	Temporary housing if displaced	Critical for seniors	Don’t skimp on this protection 🏨
Personal Liability (E)	Lawsuit protection	Grandchildren visits increase risk	$300,000 minimum recommended ⚖️
Medical Payments (F)	Guest injury expenses	Helpful regardless of fault	$5,000 typical, consider more 🏥

You may need to increase your dwelling or other structures coverage if you install accessibility features such as a stairlift or wheelchair ramp.

Another good example concerns special limits on certain types of personal property. For instance, most policies limit their coverage for the theft of furs or jewelry to $500. The limit for firearms or computers is probably $1000.

💡 Expert Insight: The most important exclusion is flood, as many people have learned to their great misfortune. If you need flood coverage, any property/casualty insurance agent can help you get it. Standard policies never cover flood damage.

🎯 Your Action Plan: Steps to Take Today

Finding the cheapest home insurance requires systematic comparison shopping and proactive discount hunting. Here’s your roadmap:

Step 1: Gather Your Information Document your home’s age, safety features, recent upgrades, and current coverage details.

Step 2: Request Multiple Quotes Different insurance companies charge different rates for the same coverage. Also, not all insurance companies provide the same level of claims service. Therefore, it makes sense to shop around for the best insurance company.

Step 3: Ask About Every Discount Ask each insurance company about discounts: Every company offers their own home insurance discounts, so make sure to ask each company that you get a quote from what discounts are available to you.

Step 4: Consider Bundling Get combined quotes for home and auto from every company you’re considering.

Step 5: Review Coverage Annually It’s important to review your homeowners insurance coverage every year. Upon renewal of your policy, include things like remodeling, new items you’ve purchased, new security equipment, or other changes that might affect your policy.

Priority Action	Potential Savings	Time Required	💡 Difficulty
Get 3+ competing quotes	15-30%	1-2 hours	Easy – do online or by phone 📞
Bundle home and auto	10-25%	30 minutes	Easy – request during quote process 📦
Increase deductible	5-12%	5 minutes	Easy – if savings available 💵
Document safety features	2-15%	30 minutes	Easy – create inventory list 📋
Install security system	5-20%	Professional install	Moderate investment required 🔐
Update electrical/plumbing	5-25%	Major project	Consider if needed anyway 🔧

✅ The Bottom Line: What You Should Do This Week

Home insurance represents a significant annual expense that compounds over your retirement years. Home insurance for seniors averages about $292 per month, but top providers like AIG, Amica, and AAA often offer lower rates.

Seniors can cut costs further by qualifying for discounts such as retiree, bundling, or security system savings. Since rates vary by coverage level and deductible, comparing providers side by side is the best way to find affordable protection.

The most effective strategy combines multiple approaches: shopping among at least three insurers, bundling policies when advantageous, claiming every available discount, choosing appropriate deductibles, and reviewing coverage annually to eliminate unnecessary protection while ensuring adequate coverage for your actual needs.

Your home is likely your most valuable asset and possibly your largest monthly expense after healthcare. Taking a few hours to optimize your insurance coverage could save hundreds or even thousands of dollars annually, money that belongs in your retirement accounts rather than insurance company profits.

Blog