Skip to content
๐Ÿ’ก Bills & utilities

My phone company says my landline is being discontinued. What are my rights?

Asked by BudgetSeniors team ยท 4 months ago

Say a letter arrives from your phone company saying your copper landline will be retired in a few weeks and you should switch to a fiber, wireless or internet-based phone. You pay about $38 a month now, you rely on the line for a medical alert pendant, and your cell signal is weak. What does a landline being discontinued mean for your rights, what does the company have to tell you, and what are your options?

1 reply

  1. BudgetSeniors team Team 4 months ago

    If a letter says your landline is being discontinued, don't sign anything and don't panic. Read the notice for the date and for what the company is offering in its place. Then call and ask three things: what the replacement is, what it costs compared with what you pay now, and what happens to your phone if the power goes out. You have more say than the letter makes it sound, though less than you had a few years ago.

    What the rules say the company has to tell you

    When a phone company wants to discontinue, reduce or impair a service, the FCC's rule at 47 CFR 63.71 says it has to notify the affected customers. We read the current text of that section. The notice has to be in writing unless the FCC allows another form in advance, and email counts as writing only if the company has your prior, verifiable approval to send notices that way and the message has a clear subject line. An email that bounces back doesn't count as notice.

    The notice has to include the company's name and address, the planned date, the area affected, a short description of the service, and a statement about how to object. That statement says the FCC will normally approve the change unless it is shown that customers would be unable to get service or a reasonable substitute from another carrier, or that the public interest is otherwise harmed. It tells you to file comments as soon as possible, and no later than 15 days after the FCC releases its public notice of the proposed discontinuance.

    Advertisement

    For a change that involves a technology transition, such as copper to fiber or to a wireless or internet-based service, the company's application to the FCC has to state the difference in price, if any, between the old service and the replacement. That sentence is worth using. Ask the company what that price difference is, and ask for it in writing.

    What changed in 2026

    The rules around copper retirement have loosened. In an order published in the Federal Register on April 20, 2026, the FCC cut back the regulatory barriers to moving from old copper networks to internet-based service, while keeping safeguards for public safety and 911 continuity. Trade-press accounts say it dropped filing requirements for network changes such as copper retirement and sped up review of discontinuance applications, while keeping public-notice duties and some consumer protections. Some of the notice and review steps described above may have changed under that order, so treat this as a general picture and ask your carrier which process applies to you.

    What that means for you in practice: the federal paperwork is lighter, the notice you get may be shorter, and the company may move faster. Your best protection is paying attention to the mail from your phone company and acting early.

    Check what depends on that copper line

    Before the date arrives, make a list of everything connected to the line. Many people forget some of these:

    • A medical alert pendant base that plugs into the phone jack.
    • A home alarm or fire alarm that calls a monitoring company.
    • A fax machine or a DSL internet connection that rides on the same line.
    • A cordless phone base. Cordless phones need household power, while an old corded phone on a copper line has traditionally worked in an outage because the line itself carries a small current. A replacement service usually doesn't do that.

    Call the medical alert and alarm companies and ask whether their equipment works with the replacement service. Some devices need a different base or a cellular unit. Ask who pays for the swap. Do this before the cutover, because a pendant that doesn't connect won't tell you it isn't working.

    Advertisement

    The replacement options and what they cost

    The company will usually offer one of a few replacements. Each has trade-offs.

    • Fiber-based phone service from the same company. Often reliable, but it needs power at your home, so a battery backup matters.
    • A voice-over-internet service. It runs on your internet connection, so your internet has to work and be powered. If you have Starlink, the dish, router and phone adapter all need power.
    • A wireless home phone, which uses a cellular signal. Coverage at your address is the key question.
    • Your own mobile phone. Many people end up here, and it is often the cheapest option if you have a signal.

    Here's a simple comparison, since real prices vary. Say you pay $38 a month for the landline, and the replacement is a $30 voice plan that requires $55 internet you don't currently have. Your new monthly total is $85, up $47 from $38. If you already have internet, the added cost is closer to the replacement voice plan itself. Always ask about the full monthly bill, including taxes, fees and equipment rental, not the headline price.

    Don't buy new internet only to keep a phone number without checking the cheaper options. A basic mobile plan, or Lifeline if you qualify, may be less expensive than a bundle.

    Power outages and 911

    A voice-over-internet phone stops working when the power fails unless it has a battery. The FCC's 911 rules for internet-based phone services require dispatchable location information in various situations, and the usual advice is to keep your registered address up to date with the provider, since an out-of-date address can send help to the wrong place. Those rules sit in 47 CFR Part 9, and the exact duties depend on your provider's type of service, so check the details with your provider. Whenever you move or change service, update the address with your phone provider.

    Ask the company in plain words: "If the power goes out, will I be able to call 911 from this phone, and for how long?" Ask what battery comes with the equipment, how long it lasts, and who replaces it. If the answers are vague, keep a charged mobile phone as your backup and check that it gets a signal inside your home.

    What you can do if you object

    You do have routes, and none of them cost money.

    • Read the notice for the docket or the contact information it gives for objections. File a comment with the FCC by the deadline in the notice, if you want your concerns on the record. Your comment should say specifically how the change affects you, such as a lack of cell signal or a medical device that depends on the line.
    • Contact your state public utility commission. Many state commissions handle phone complaints and have their own rules. Search for your state's name and "public utility commission consumer complaint".
    • Your Area Agency on Aging can help you write a letter; the Eldercare Locator, 1-800-677-1116, will point you to it.
    • If you can't get an acceptable replacement at your address, say so in writing to the company and to the commission. The rule's own statement says the FCC looks at whether customers would be unable to receive service or a reasonable substitute.

    Keep copies of every letter and note the date and name of everyone you speak to. Don't agree to a new contract over the phone on the day of the first call. Ask for the offer in writing and take a few days.

    Scams that follow these notices

    News about copper retirement gives scammers an opening. If a caller says your line will be shut off today unless you pay or buy a package, hang up. Phone companies don't ask for gift cards or wire transfers. If you've already paid someone, call your bank, then file with the FTC's ReportFraud site and the FBI's IC3. Call AARP's free Fraud Watch Helpline, 877-908-3360, if you want to talk it over.

    A checklist for this week

    • Find the letter. Write down the date, the replacement and the contact number.
    • List everything on the line: alert pendant, alarm, fax, DSL.
    • Call the company and ask for the price difference in writing.
    • Test your cell signal inside the house.
    • Ask about battery backup and how long it lasts.
    • Note the comment deadline if you want to object.

    This is general information, not legal advice, and the rules changed in 2026, so details can differ for your carrier and state. When in doubt, ask your state commission what rights apply to your account.

    Key sources: FCC; Federal Register; eCFR

Add your reply

Your email is never shown. Be kind โ€” someone may be worried about money. Never post account, Social Security or Medicare numbers.