Skip to content
๐Ÿฉบ Medicare & health costs

Are OTC hearing aids good enough, or do I need an audiologist-fitted pair?

Asked by BudgetSeniors team ยท 4 months ago

Say you’re 70, living on $1,700 a month, and you’ve noticed muffled speech, trouble in restaurants and a TV volume your family complains about. A hearing test and fitted hearing aids from a clinic could run several thousand dollars, Medicare doesn’t pay for them, and you’ve seen over-the-counter hearing aids advertised for a few hundred. You don’t know whether the cheap ones are safe, who they suit, or what to check before buying. This answer compares OTC hearing aids with audiologist-fitted ones on cost and fit, lists the warning signs that call for a doctor first, and explains what the label and return policy should tell you.

1 reply

  1. BudgetSeniors team Team 4 months ago

    If your trouble is following talk in a noisy restaurant, turning the TV up past what the rest of the family likes, and asking people to repeat themselves, over-the-counter hearing aids are a reasonable first try at a few hundred dollars. If your hearing is worse than that, or if one ear is worse than the other, or if anything on FDA's warning list below applies to you, start with a doctor or audiologist instead. Either way, Original Medicare won't pay for the devices.

    What OTC hearing aids are, and who they're for

    FDA created the over-the-counter category, and it took effect on October 17, 2022. These devices are for adults 18 and older with perceived mild to moderate hearing loss. You can buy them in a store or online without a prescription, a medical exam or an audiologist's fitting, and you set them up yourself, often with a smartphone app. They aren't meant for severe or profound loss. FDA explains why: OTC models are limited in how loud they can get, so they may not help enough with a bigger loss.

    FDA's page says close to 30 million U.S. adults have some hearing loss, but only about one in five who could benefit seeks help. And it says hearing aids may reduce the frequency or severity of cognitive decline, depression and other health problems in adults. Those are reasons not to put this off because of price.

    Advertisement

    NIDCD, the National Institute on Deafness and Other Communication Disorders, lists signs of mild to moderate loss: speech sounds muffled, trouble hearing in groups, noise or on the phone, asking people to speak slowly or repeat, and turning up the volume higher than others like. If you have trouble hearing conversations in quiet settings or hearing loud sounds, it advises seeing a hearing health professional.

    When to see a doctor before buying anything

    FDA's required package labeling lists "red flag" conditions. Please see a doctor, preferably an ear-nose-throat doctor, if you have any of these:

    • blood, pus or fluid coming from the ear in the past 6 months
    • an ear that feels painful or uncomfortable
    • a lot of earwax, or a feeling something is in your ear
    • a birth defect, an unusual ear shape or an injury to the ear
    • strong dizziness or a spinning feeling
    • hearing that changed suddenly in the past 6 months, or that gets worse and then better again
    • worse hearing in one ear, or ringing or buzzing in only one ear

    One-sided changes and sudden changes can have medical causes that a hearing aid won't fix, so skip the shopping and get checked first.

    What it costs: our comparison

    Medicare.gov is clear that Original Medicare pays nothing toward hearing aids or the fitting exams. It does help with diagnostic hearing and balance exams that your doctor orders, at 20% coinsurance once the Part B deductible is met. Some Advantage plans offer hearing benefits, and KFF's 2026 data found 95% of enrollees in individual Advantage plans are in plans with hearing exams or aids. Check the dollar limit before counting on it.

    For prices, we used HearingTracker's survey of U.S. buyers (879 pair purchases, mostly from its own readers, so it isn't a random sample). The average price paid per pair was:

    • over-the-counter: $502, with a median of $200
    • Costco: $1,674
    • traditional clinic with insurance: $2,567
    • traditional clinic without insurance: $4,727

    Because OTC prices were so low in that survey, we ran a simple comparison. Suppose you pay $500 for an OTC pair and it works. You've spent $500 against $4,727. If it doesn't work and you then buy fitted aids at a clinic at the average price, you've spent $5,227 total, but only if you can't return the OTC pair. That's the reason to check the return policy before you buy. FDA says its regulations don't require a warranty, and the box must state the return policy or say there isn't one, so read it. Look for a trial period long enough to test the devices at home, outside and in a restaurant.

    Advertisement

    What a clinic gives you that a box doesn't

    A licensed professional tests your hearing, fits and programs the devices, and adjusts them over time. FDA notes prescription hearing aids are only available through licensed professionals, can suit all levels of loss, and are the route for severe hearing loss. If you have a bigger loss, or you struggle with apps and tiny controls, that support is what you're paying for. The survey's lower-cost route, Costco, sells prescription devices with fitting, though we didn't check what its price includes.

    You can also buy an OTC device from a hearing professional, who can test you and evaluate the fit. And FDA says you can ask a professional for your hearing evaluation records, in case you want to buy elsewhere.

    Reading the box

    FDA's labeling rules require, on the outside of the box, the words "OTC" and "hearing aid," warnings about when to seek care, battery information, whether you need a phone to control it, and the return policy. FDA says "FDA Registered" or "FDA Certified" statements and use of an FDA logo may be misleading, so don't treat them as quality marks. Personal sound amplifiers are a different class of product. NIDCD says they're for people without hearing loss and aren't regulated as medical devices, so a cheap amplifier isn't the same as an OTC hearing aid.

    After you buy

    Plan on a few weeks of adjustment. FDA says it takes time and practice to get used to hearing aids, so wear them regularly and learn the settings. If you aren't getting benefit, consult a hearing health professional. If a device hurts, irritates your ear canal, or malfunctions, tell FDA through MedWatch at 1-800-FDA-1088.

    Ways to lower the cost

    • Ask whether your Advantage plan, Medicaid in your state, or any other coverage you have pays part of it.
    • Get quotes from at least three sellers, including one warehouse club and one clinic.
    • Ask a clinic what's bundled: fittings, follow-up visits, cleaning.
    • The Eldercare Locator, 1-800-677-1116, can steer you to an Area Agency on Aging that may list local hearing-aid programs.

    Don't borrow, run up a credit card or take a loan with high fees to buy hearing aids, and be wary of mailers promising miracle devices. If a mailer or caller talked you into a scam purchase, tell your bank and file a report through the FTC's ReportFraud site.

    This is general information, not medical advice. A hearing test is the only way to know where you stand.

    Key sources: FDA; NIDCD; Medicare.gov

Add your reply

Your email is never shown. Be kind โ€” someone may be worried about money. Never post account, Social Security or Medicare numbers.