My landline keeps getting pricier. What’s the cheapest home phone service that still reaches 911?
Say your landline now costs $55 a month with taxes and fees, and the bill went up again. You mostly use it for a few family calls, a doctor’s office, and a medical alert pendant that plugs into the wall. You’ve been told you could switch to an internet phone, a phone app or just a cell phone, but you worry about what happens during a power outage, whether 911 works, and whether you’d lose your number. You’d like a clear way to compare the options and a checklist to avoid cutting off something you rely on.
1 reply
-
๐ก BudgetSeniors team Team 2 months ago Before you cancel anything, decide what your home phone has to do when the power goes out, because that decides which cheap option is safe. If the phone is also how your medical alert pendant, alarm system or a relative reaches you, the cheapest plan on paper can be the wrong one. If it's just a number people call, you have a lot of low-cost choices.
The usual savings come from three moves. You can drop the landline and use a cell phone for everything. You can keep a regular phone plugged into a cheaper internet-based (VoIP) service. Or you can keep your number as an app or low-cost line. Each saves money, and each has a catch about 911 and power.
The worked example
Say your landline costs $55 a month with taxes and fees, and a VoIP plan from your internet provider or another company runs $20 a month all in. That's $35 a month saved, or $420 a year. Say the plan needs a $60 adapter. You'd earn it back in under two months. The number that matters is the all-in price, so ask for the monthly total with taxes, fees and equipment before you agree, because the headline price can leave them out. Compare that to what you pay now.
AdvertisementIf you already have a cell phone and nobody calls the house line, dropping it saves the full $55. Your cell plan carries on, and you can give out that number instead. We covered cheap cell plans in an earlier answer.
What changes when your phone runs on the internet
A traditional copper landline is powered through the phone line itself, so it typically keeps working in a power outage. A VoIP line goes through your modem and router, and those need electricity.
The FCC's own compliance guide for its 2015 backup-power rules explains the idea. Providers of fixed home voice service that isn't powered through the line had to offer customers, at the point of sale, a backup-power option with at least eight hours of standby power, and later an option with at least 24 hours, and had to explain at sale and every year after how the service behaves in a power outage. The guide also says the backup covers the equipment needed for 911 access, not other services, and that providers should warn customers that things like home security and medical-monitoring devices won't be powered by it.
Here's the part to take seriously. The rule itself set those requirements to end on September 1, 2025. So don't assume your provider will hand you a backup battery or even mention it. Ask directly: "If the power goes out, will my phone work? For how long? What battery do I need, how much is it, and how do I know when it's dead?" Write down the answer. Then put a reminder on the calendar to check the battery each year, since batteries wear out.
Calling 911 on an internet phone
Federal rules require providers of interconnected VoIP service to provide 911 service to the customer, and to send each 911 call to the emergency answering point along with location information. For a fixed home service, the rule calls for an automatically supplied dispatchable location. The rules define registered location as the most recent physical location the provider has on file for you. So if you move, or take the adapter to a daughter's house, update your address with the provider first. Otherwise a 911 call could show the wrong address.
AdvertisementNot every internet calling product works the same way. Google Voice's help page says emergency calling is available only for certain account types, namely Voice Starter and Voice Standard standalone accounts and Workspace add-on accounts managed by work or school, and that it won't work during a power outage, loss of your internet connection, or a Google Voice outage. The page tells users to use an alternative phone service to reach emergency services, and notes that any phone, even a mobile phone with no account or plan, can call emergency services. A free app number is fine for family calls. It's a poor choice as your only line if you rely on it in an emergency.
Option by option
- Cell phone only. Cheapest, and works in an outage as long as it's charged and has signal. If you live where signal is weak, test it from the room where you'd actually use it. Keep a car charger or a power bank.
- VoIP from your cable or internet company. Sometimes bundled with internet. You keep a regular handset and a familiar setup. Check the all-in price, the 911 setup and whether it has battery backup. If you ever lose internet, you lose the phone.
- Independent VoIP provider. Plans vary a lot in price and in how they handle number transfers, 911 and equipment. Read the provider's own price page and its 911 terms, and don't rely on a list from a website that earns commissions.
- Keep the copper landline. It costs more, but if you depend on the phone working in outages, or you live where cell coverage is poor, it can be worth it. Ask the phone company what it plans for the line, since providers have been moving customers off copper in some areas.
- Lifeline. If your income is low, the federal Lifeline program can reduce a phone or internet bill. We covered it in an earlier answer.
Switching without losing your number
If you want to keep your number, don't cancel your old service first. Sign up with the new provider, ask them to "port" your number, and let them handle the transfer. Once the port is complete and calls work, cancel the old line. If you cancel first, you can lose the number.
Before you disconnect, make a list of everything that uses the line:
- A medical alert pendant or base station.
- A home alarm or monitoring service.
- Fax or a satellite or cable box that dials in.
- Credit and bank "call-back" verification and your doctor's office.
Call the medical alert and alarm companies and ask if their equipment works on VoIP or cellular. Some need an upgrade. Don't just assume.
Scams around phone service
When people switch services, scammers call claiming to be from your phone company, saying your line will be shut off unless you pay by gift card or wire. Real phone companies don't ask for gift cards. Hang up, look up the company's number on your own bill, and call that. If you've paid or given out information, report it to the FTC at ReportFraud. The AARP Fraud Watch Helpline, 877-908-3360, is there for a call as well. When you want help comparing options, the Eldercare Locator (1-800-677-1116) can point you to your Area Agency on Aging, and that office may know of local resources.
A short checklist
- Get the all-in monthly price for every option.
- Ask each provider what happens in a power outage and how long.
- Keep a charged cell phone for 911 as your backup.
- Update your address if you move.
- Port the number before cancelling.
This is general information. Services and prices vary by provider and area, so confirm the details with the provider before you switch.
Key sources: FCC; Google Voice Help