What’s the cheapest way to get a decent smartphone for my mother, who’s 74?
Say your mother is 74, her old phone barely holds a charge, and the carrier store quoted a new smartphone on a $25-a-month payment plan for 24 months. She mostly makes calls, sends a few texts and wants video calls with the grandchildren. You’ve heard about refurbished phones, trade-ins and prepaid plans but don’t know which are safe, what warranty to expect, or whether a locked phone will work on a cheaper plan. How do you compare the real two-year cost of each route?
1 reply
-
๐ก BudgetSeniors team Team 5 months ago The cheapest phone for an older adult is usually not the cheapest phone on the shelf. It's a recent, used or refurbished, carrier-free model with a warranty, paired with a low-cost prepaid plan, bought only after you've asked what the phone will actually be used for. Here's how to price that out in an afternoon, with no pressure to buy anything today.
First, a reality check. Many older adults don't need a new phone at all. If the phone you have still gets software updates, holds a charge through the day and does what you need, a new battery or a larger text size setting may fix the problem. Ask a family member or your library's tech help desk to look before you spend.
Decide what the phone is for
Write down the five things you'd do with it: calls, texts, photos, video calls with grandchildren, maps. If it's mostly calls and texts, a simple phone is fine. If it's video calls and photos, you need a decent screen and camera, and that's where refurbished smartphones earn their keep.
Also think about hands and eyes. A bigger screen, loud speaker, hearing-aid compatibility and a simple home screen matter more than the processor. Try one in a store before buying, even if you'll buy elsewhere.
AdvertisementRefurbished: what you actually get
Apple's own refurbished store page says its Apple Certified Refurbished products are cleaned, inspected and tested, that refurbished iPhones and iPads come with a new battery and outer shell, and that every one carries its standard one-year limited warranty, with free shipping and returns. Apple also says savings run up to 15 percent. That's a modest saving, so for Apple the "refurbished from the maker" route buys you reliability more than a deep discount.
For Android and for other sellers, ask what the seller's refurbishing standard is. Ask four things: Is the phone free to use on any carrier, or locked to one? Is the battery new or tested, and what's its health? How long is the warranty, and who honors it? What's the return window? If a seller can't answer in writing, buy elsewhere. A very low price on an unnamed seller's page is a warning sign.
A worked example
Say you're comparing three ways to get a phone with a good camera.
- New phone at a carrier store, on a payment plan of $25 a month for 24 months. That's $600, plus a monthly plan.
- Refurbished model from the maker or a reputable seller, a couple of generations old, for a one-time price you'd pay up front, which we'll say is $300.
- Your current phone with a battery replacement, priced by a local repair shop.
The payment plan costs $600 over two years. The refurbished phone costs half that, if the price is as stated, and keeps working with updates for a few years. And if the current phone does what you need, a repair may be cheaper than either. Real prices will differ, so use these numbers to see how to line the options up, and get a quote for your own phone.
Never put a phone on a payment plan you can't comfortably cover. Don't borrow, and don't take out store credit, to chase a phone deal.
Trade-ins
Apple says its Trade In program gives credit toward a new device, and that if your device isn't eligible for credit, they'll recycle it free. Carriers and other stores have their own programs, with their own terms. Carrier trade-in offers can come with strings, such as a required new line or bill credits spread over many months that stop if you leave early. Read the terms and ask the clerk: "If I cancel in month 10, what do I still owe?" If the deal only works when you sign a long contract, it may not be a deal.
AdvertisementBefore trading in or giving away any phone, back up photos and contacts, sign out of your accounts, and erase the phone. Ask a trusted person to help with this; the steps differ by phone.
Prepaid versus monthly plans
A prepaid plan means you pay in advance, usually for a month at a time, with no credit check and no long contract. Someone who mostly calls and texts may pay less this way than on a big-carrier plan, but compare the actual monthly totals. We covered how to choose a cheap plan in general in an earlier answer, so here are only the phone-specific points.
- Buy a phone that isn't locked to one carrier, or check that a locked one will work on the plan you want. A phone locked to one carrier may not work on another until the lock is removed.
- Check the phone works on the network the plan uses. Ask the plan's company, in writing if possible, whether a specific model is supported.
- Ask about Wi-Fi calling if your home has weak signal.
- Ask whether the plan has a hearing-aid-compatible phone list, if that matters to you.
Lifeline and other help with the phone bill
If your income is low, you may qualify for Lifeline, a federal program that discounts phone or internet service. It doesn't buy the phone, but it can lower the monthly bill. The program has its own eligibility rules, and we covered it in an earlier answer, so check the details with the program's official administrator before giving anyone your information, and be wary of any "free phone" offer that reaches you by call or text.
Safe places to buy
- The manufacturer's own refurbished store.
- A carrier store or major retailer with a clear return policy.
- A local repair shop that sells used phones with a warranty.
- Online marketplaces only if the seller's return and warranty policies are written and you can pay with a method that offers protection.
Avoid buying a used phone from a stranger in a parking lot. A phone reported lost or stolen may be blocked, and you could be left with a brick. Ask the seller to show the phone isn't locked to a carrier or tied to someone else's account, and check it before you pay.
Scam warnings
Calls or texts about a "free phone" that ask for your Social Security number, bank details or a gift card are scams. Hang up, don't click, and don't pay. If money has already gone out, phone your bank first. After that, file reports with the FTC's ReportFraud site and the FBI's IC3. For next steps, the AARP Fraud Watch Helpline, 877-908-3360, is a good number to have.
Questions to ask at any store
- What's the total cost over two years, including taxes and fees?
- Is the phone free to use on any carrier, or locked to one?
- What's the return window, and is there a restocking fee?
- Does it work with my hearing aids, and can I try it?
- Is the price the same without a trade-in?
Offers change often, so check the seller's own page or ask at the counter. This is general information, not a recommendation to buy any brand.
Key sources: Apple (refurbished and trade-in pages); Consumer Financial Protection Bureau