Is Cost Plus Drugs or Amazon RxPass actually cheaper than my Part D copays?
Say you take three generic prescriptions a month, such as one for blood pressure, one for cholesterol and one for thyroid, and your Part D plan charges about $10 for each at the local pharmacy. A neighbor mentioned Cost Plus Drugs, a mail-order cash pharmacy, and you’ve also seen Amazon’s RxPass at a flat $5 a month for Prime members. You aren’t sure whether paying cash outside your plan counts toward your deductible, or whether the shipping and pharmacy fees eat the savings. How do you compare them fairly, and when is staying with your plan the cheaper choice?
1 reply
-
๐ก BudgetSeniors team Team 1 month ago Whether Cost Plus Drugs beats your Part D copay comes down to one comparison, and it takes about ten minutes: what you pay at the counter now for each pill, against what the cash price on the Cost Plus site works out to after the pharmacy fee and shipping. If the cash price is lower, ordering from them can save real money. If your plan already charges a few dollars, it usually can't.
Start with the three things people mix up. Cost Plus Drugs is a mail-order cash pharmacy. Amazon RxPass is a flat monthly subscription for a list of generics. A pharmacy discount card is a coupon you hand the pharmacist. They solve different problems, and none of them replaces your insurance.
How Cost Plus Drugs prices a prescription
The idea is simple. The company lists what the drug costs it, adds a fixed percentage markup, then adds a pharmacy fee and a shipping charge. Drug Topics, a pharmacy trade publication, wrote in its September/October 2026 issue that cash-pay pharmacies of this kind advertise ingredient cost plus a flat markup, a $3 pharmacy fee and $5 shipping. Fees like those can change, so read the checkout screen, not an article, for the real number.
AdvertisementBecause shipping and the fee are flat, the size of the fill matters. The same article cites a study that compared Mark Cuban Cost Plus Drug Company prices with what Medicare spent on 15 generics. For 30-count fills, only 9 of the 15 drugs came out cheaper, and averaged across all 15 the Cost Plus price was about 14.85 percent higher than Medicare's, which the authors blamed partly on the flat $5 shipping fee weighing heavily on small fills. For 90-count fills, 12 of 15 were cheaper, with an average reduction of 31.63 percent. Those are study results for one set of drugs, not a promise about yours, but the pattern is useful: a 90-day supply spreads the fixed fees thinner.
A worked example with real numbers
Say you take three generics and your Part D plan charges a $10 copay on each, filled monthly at a local pharmacy. That's $30 a month, or $360 a year.
Now say the cash prices for a 90-day supply come to $9, $12 and $15, which is $36 for the three, and each separate order adds about $8 in pharmacy fee and shipping. Three orders would add $24, so the quarter costs $60, against $90 through the plan for the same three months. If the site lets you put all three drugs in one order and charges the fee and shipping once, you'd pay about $44. Your own drugs will price differently, so type them in and see.
Flip it. Say your plan charges $0 on a tier-one generic. Nothing beats $0, and mailing in a cash order only makes sense if the pharmacy doesn't stock the drug or you're between plans.
What you give up when you pay cash
This is the catch people miss. When you pay a cash pharmacy outside your plan, that purchase generally doesn't get reported to your plan, so it may not count toward your deductible or toward the yearly out-of-pocket cap, which is $2,400 for Part D in 2027. If you're heading toward that cap with expensive brand-name drugs, buying a cheap generic outside the plan matters little. If your drug list is all low-cost generics, you'll probably never reach the cap anyway. Ask your plan, or your State Health Insurance Assistance Program counselor, how they treat cash purchases before you assume either way.
AdvertisementTwo more limits. Cost Plus doesn't stock every drug, so a regimen split between two pharmacies needs care. Drug Topics flagged that splitting medicines across pharmacies can raise the risk of medication errors or missed interactions. Tell each pharmacist about everything you take, or keep one list in your wallet and bring it to every refill.
And the same article describes the cash model as a poor fit for expensive brand-name specialty drugs and for people on Medicaid, where existing coverage is generally the cheaper route.
Amazon RxPass: the flat-fee option
Amazon's own RxPass page says the subscription is $5 a month no matter how many eligible medications you take, that it covers more than 50 commonly prescribed generics, and that you need an Amazon Prime membership first. Amazon's own Prime page lists $14.99 a month, or $139 a year if you pay annually, so the fair comparison for a non-member is the Prime fee plus $5, not $5 alone. Prices change, so check the sign-up page.
The fine print matters here. Amazon says RxPass isn't insurance, you can't pay the RxPass fee with an HSA or FSA, people on state-funded coverage such as Medicaid and CHIP can't sign up right now, and it isn't currently available to ship to California or Washington. Amazon's page says it's worth a look if you're paying more than $5 a month for all your eligible medications combined.
Run the same math. Say you pay $10 each for three eligible generics through your plan. RxPass would cost $5 a month instead of $30, saving $25 a month, or $300 a year, if you're already a Prime member and every drug is on the list. If you'd join Prime only for this, add the Prime fee and the savings shrink or disappear. And if your plan copays are $0 to $3, RxPass has little to offer.
Discount cards and the plain pharmacy
A pharmacy discount card works differently from both of these. You show it at a regular pharmacy, and the price comes down for that single prescription. We covered how that compares with Part D in an earlier answer, so the short version is: check the card price against your copay on the same day, and ask the pharmacist to run both.
It's also worth asking your own pharmacist for the cash price of a 90-day supply and whether the store has a list of low-priced generics. Some do. Nobody is offended by the question, and a local pharmacy can fix a refill problem the same afternoon, which a mail-order house can't.
The ten-minute comparison
- Write down each drug, the strength and how many tablets you take a day.
- Look up what your plan charges for it, for 30 days and for 90 days. Your plan's formulary or the Medicare Plan Finder shows the tier.
- Price the same drug in the Cost Plus listing, add the fees shown at checkout, and divide by the number of months.
- Check whether RxPass lists the drug, if you already have Prime.
- Ask your pharmacist what a cash or discount card price would be today.
- Pick the lowest total per month, and remember that cash purchases may not count toward your plan's cap.
When not to bother
If your monthly drug bill is under about ten dollars, stay put. If you rely on a brand-name drug, a cash price will almost never beat insurance. If you're in a Medicaid plan, use it.
If your costs are high even with coverage, the better move is usually a different one: a Part D plan review during open enrollment, the low-income drug help your state or Social Security office can explain, or a free session with your State Health Insurance Assistance Program counselor. Those are free. Nobody should charge you to compare plans.
This is general information and not medical or financial advice. Never change how you take a medicine to save money, and talk to your doctor or pharmacist before swapping any prescription for a different supplier. Order only from a pharmacy that requires a valid prescription from your prescriber, and be wary of any site that doesn't ask for one.
If a stranger phones offering "discount drug cards" or "Medicare-approved savings" and asks for your Medicare number, hang up and tell the FTC through its ReportFraud site. You can also talk it over with the AARP Fraud Watch Helpline at 877-908-3360.
Key sources: Drug Topics; Amazon Pharmacy (RxPass page); Medicare