Skip to content
๐Ÿท๏ธ Senior discounts

I drive about 3,000 miles a year. Would pay per mile insurance actually cost me less?

Asked by BudgetSeniors team ยท 1 month ago

Say you’re retired, drive about 3,000 miles a year to church, the pharmacy and the grocery store, and pay $95 a month for car insurance with a clean record. You’ve seen ads for pay-per-mile insurance with a monthly base rate plus a few cents a mile and a plug-in device that tracks your driving. You can’t tell whether the fixed part would eat the savings, what happens on a rare long trip to see family, whether it’s offered in your state, and what privacy you give up. You’d like the break-even math and the questions to ask before you switch.

1 reply

  1. BudgetSeniors team Team 1 month ago

    Pay-per-mile insurance can be cheaper at 3,000 miles a year, but only if the fixed monthly part of the bill is low enough, so get the base rate and the per-mile rate in writing and run one small calculation before you switch. Here it is. Say a pay-per-mile policy has a base premium of $55 a month and charges 7 cents a mile. At 3,000 miles a year you drive about 250 miles a month, so you'd pay $55 plus $17.50, or $72.50 a month, which is $870 a year. If your current policy is $95 a month, that's $1,140 a year, and the switch saves $270. Your own numbers will differ, but the method is the same.

    The break-even point is where the two bills are equal. Take the $95 policy and the $55 base: the $40 gap divided by 7 cents is about 571 miles a month, or roughly 6,860 miles a year. Drive less than that and the pay-per-mile plan wins in this example. Drive more and it loses. That one number, your break-even mileage, is what to compare against what you actually drive.

    How pay-per-mile works, in the insurers' own words

    Nationwide's SmartMiles page describes a premium in two parts: a base premium and a variable premium based on a cost per mile. The page says the base premium and the cost per mile don't change during the policy term unless you change the policy, and that your monthly payment is the base premium plus the cost per mile multiplied by the miles you drove in the prior billing cycle, typically the prior month. Mileage is measured by a small plug-in device or by an eligible connected car. The page says only the first 250 miles on a single day count, which softens the cost of a long drive to see family. It also says you can earn up to a 10 percent safe-driving discount after your first renewal, which means the company is also looking at how you drive, not only how far.

    Advertisement

    The same page lists limits worth reading. Most vehicles made after 1996 are eligible, but some hybrids, electric cars and diesel cars may not work with the device. And SmartMiles isn't available in Alaska, Hawaii, Louisiana, Michigan, North Carolina, New York or Oklahoma. Availability and program rules vary by state and over time, so ask an agent in your state.

    Allstate's Milewise help page describes something similar: a pay-as-you-go product that uses a device to capture miles, with an app so you can see your driving and costs. With its Pay-Per-Mile option you pay a daily rate plus a per-mile rate, and with the Unlimited option you pay a daily rate only. You can pick one or a combination for the vehicles on a policy. The daily rate is a different structure from a monthly base, so convert to a monthly number to compare.

    These are two examples of how the products work, not recommendations. Other companies sell them too, and your state's availability and prices may be different.

    Who it fits, and who it doesn't

    It tends to fit people who drive well below the average, such as retirees who only go to church, the pharmacy and the grocery store, or couples with a second car that rarely moves. Nationwide's own page lists examples like a short commute, working from home, an extra car you rarely drive, or frequent use of public transit.

    It's a poor fit if your mileage creeps up in some months because of doctor visits, a trip, or helping a relative. It's also a poor fit if your base rate is high, since that fixed part is paid whether or not you drive. And it requires a device or connected car that tracks your driving, so ask exactly what's collected, who sees it, how long they keep it and whether it can raise your price.

    Ask these questions before you switch

    • What are the base premium and the per-mile rate, written out for my exact coverage?
    • Are the coverage limits the same as on my current policy? Compare the same liability limits, deductibles and any roadside or rental coverage.
    • Is there a daily cap on miles, like 250, and does it apply to every day or only some?
    • How is mileage measured, and what happens if the device is unplugged or my car isn't compatible?
    • What does the device or app collect besides miles?
    • Is it available in my state, and are there fees to start or cancel?
    • Can I go back to a regular policy later without a penalty?
    Advertisement

    Cheaper alternatives to check first

    You don't need pay-per-mile to get a low-mileage break. Ask your current insurer, in a phone call, what discounts they offer for low annual mileage, for being retired, for paying in full or by bank draft, for having a clean record and for completing a defensive-driving course. Nationwide's page also mentions SmartRide, a safe-driving discount program for traditional policies that it says can earn up to 40 percent in most states, but that discount depends on your driving behavior and the amount varies. Get at least three quotes on identical coverage, from agents or the companies directly.

    Your state insurance department's website may have a shopper's guide and a complaint history for insurers, and it's a good place to verify a company is licensed to sell in your state.

    What not to cut

    Don't drop liability coverage to save money, and don't let a policy lapse while you switch. Your state sets minimum coverage and penalties for driving without insurance, and a gap in coverage can cause real trouble. Start the new policy before ending the old one, and get the new proof of insurance in your hands. If you rarely drive, you still need protection against a crash that's your fault, and against damage to your car if you own it outright or have a loan.

    If you've stopped driving altogether, ask your agent what coverage a parked car still needs before you cancel anything on your own.

    A short plan

    • Find your annual mileage from your last two oil change or inspection records, and divide by 12.
    • Get quotes with the base rate and the per-mile rate, and compute the break-even.
    • Compare the result against a quote for a traditional policy with a low-mileage discount.
    • Read the data-collection terms before you plug anything in.
    • Switch only if the savings hold up in a typical year and in a busy one.

    If an offer arrives by phone or text promising big savings for a card number up front, hang up. Call the company using the number on your current insurance card. The AARP Fraud Watch Helpline, 877-908-3360, can help if you're unsure.

    This is general information, not insurance advice. Your agent or your state insurance department can answer questions about your coverage.

    Key sources: Nationwide; Allstate

Add your reply

Your email is never shown. Be kind โ€” someone may be worried about money. Never post account, Social Security or Medicare numbers.