How many days can a Canadian snowbird spend in the US before the IRS calls them a resident?
Say you are a Canadian retiree who spends about 150 days each winter in Florida or Arizona, and you kept your house, health card and bank accounts in Canada. You have heard 183 days is the limit, but a friend says the IRS counts past years too, and that you must file Form 8840 even with no US income. Which days count, what does the filing do, what happens if it is missed, and what does a long winter away do to your OAS, GIS and provincial health cover?
1 reply
-
๐ก BudgetSeniors team Team 2 months ago Count your days first, using the IRS formula and not the plain "under 183 days" rule most snowbirds quote. If you spend 150 days a year in Florida or Arizona, you are under 183 in each calendar year, yet you still meet the IRS substantial presence test. What keeps you a nonresident for US tax is a filing, Form 8840, sent on time. Skip it and the IRS can count every day against you.
This is about Canadian snowbirds spending winters in the United States, and it touches both countries: US tax rules, and the Canadian rules that decide whether your pension and provincial health cover survive a long absence. It is general information, not tax advice. A cross-border tax professional is worth paying once if your situation is complicated.
The US test is a three-year formula
The IRS treats you as a US resident for tax purposes if you meet the substantial presence test. You must be in the United States at least 31 days in the current year, and at least 183 days over a three-year period counted this way: every day this year, plus one-third of last year's days, plus one-sixth of the days two years ago. Any part of a day in the US counts as a day, apart from a few exceptions, such as being in transit for under 24 hours between two places outside the US.
AdvertisementThree snowbird examples:
- 110 days each year for three years: 110 + 36.7 + 18.3 = 165. Under 183, so you do not meet the test and no closer connection form is needed.
- 120 days each year: 120 + 40 + 20 = 180. The IRS uses this very example, and it also comes out under 183. By our arithmetic the most you can stay every single year and stay under is 121 days (121 + 40.3 + 20.2 is about 181.5), and 122 days a year reaches 183.
- 150 days each year: 150 + 50 + 25 = 225. You meet the test even though you were under 183 days that year.
The closer connection exception and Form 8840
If you meet the test, you can still be treated as a nonresident if you were in the US fewer than 183 days in the current year, you kept a tax home in Canada for the whole year, you had a closer connection to Canada than to the US, and you had not applied, or taken steps to apply, for a green card. The IRS looks at facts such as where your permanent home is, where your family and belongings are, where you vote and hold a driver's license, which forms you file (the country of residence you state on a Form W-9 or W-8BEN), your social, cultural and religious ties, and the charities you give to. It does not matter whether the home is owned or rented, as long as it is available to you all year and not only for short stays.
You claim the exception on Form 8840, Closer Connection Exception Statement for Aliens. If you must file a US return, it is attached to that return. If you are not required to file one, you send the statement to the IRS by the date a nonresident return would be due for that year, including extensions. The 2026 form says to mail it to the IRS in Austin, Texas, by the due date (including extensions) for Form 1040-NR. For most snowbirds with no US wages, that has been June 15 of the following year, but confirm the date in the current Form 8840 instructions for the year you are filing.
AdvertisementThe penalty for a missed filing is not a fine. Under the Treasury regulation, if you fail to file on time, you lose the closer connection exception and must count all your days in the US. The one exception is if you can show by clear and convincing evidence that you took reasonable steps to learn about the filing and significant steps to comply. If you could not leave because of a medical condition that arose while you were in the US, those days can be excluded, but you must file Form 8843 on time to do so.
Note also: 183 days or more in one year rules out the exception altogether. And if Canada and the US could both treat you as resident, the regulation sends you to the tax treaty to settle it.
The Canadian side: pension and health cover
Old Age Security. Under the Old Age Security Act, if you remain outside Canada for six consecutive months, not counting the month you left, the pension is suspended after that. The exception: if you had lived in Canada for at least 20 years after age 18 when you left, the pension can continue. The Guaranteed Income Supplement is different. As we read the Act, no supplement is paid for any month after you have been absent for six consecutive months, and the 20-year exception sits in the pension section, not in the supplement section. If you get GIS, keep your winter stays under six months in a row and check with Service Canada before you book a longer one.
Provincial health insurance. Rules differ by province. Ontario's page explains that if your plans take you out of Canada for more than 7 months within any 12-month stretch, OHIP can stay active for as long as 2 years, but only when you satisfy certain requirements. One of them is having spent at least 153 days in Ontario during each of the two 12-month periods just before. For emergencies in the US, OHIP pays only a set rate, and it is small: the lesser of what was billed or up to C$50 a day for emergency outpatient hospital care. For inpatient stays, the daily ceiling is C$400 if you're in an operating room, coronary care or intensive care unit, and C$200 a day for lower levels of care. OHIP will not pay to move you home from a foreign hospital, so the province urges you to carry travel medical insurance that includes transportation back.
That gap is the real snowbird cost. OHIP pays fixed daily amounts, while a US hospital sets its own prices, so whatever the bill is above C$400 a day lands on you unless you are insured. Private travel medical insurance is how you cover it. Compare policies for pre-existing condition rules and whether they cover the return trip.
A short checklist
- Keep a day log (a calendar will do) and your boarding passes or border records. You may need to show them.
- Keep your Canadian ties current: a home or lease you can return to, driver's license, health card, bank accounts, doctors.
- File Form 8840 each year you meet the substantial presence test, on time.
- Check your OAS and GIS months away with Service Canada, and your health card rules with your province.
- Beware of anyone who contacts you claiming to be from the IRS or CRA and demanding payment by gift card or crypto. Hang up and call the agency yourself.
This is general information only. Rules and filing dates change, so confirm with the IRS and the Canada Revenue Agency, or a qualified cross-border tax adviser.
Key sources: Internal Revenue Service; Old Age Security Act (Justice Laws); Ontario Ministry of Health