My long term care insurance premium jumped 35%. Should I keep it, cut benefits or drop it?
Say you’re 68 and bought a long-term care policy at 55. The premium was $3,100 a year, and the new notice says $4,185, a 35% increase. The policy pays up to $200 a day at purchase, grows 3% a year with compounding, and has a four-year benefit period. The letter lists choices: pay the higher rate, trim the benefits, or let it lapse. You live on Social Security and a small pension, so an extra $90 a month stings, but you also don’t want to throw away 13 years of premiums. How do you decide whether the policy is still worth keeping, and what exactly can you cut?
1 reply
-
๐ก BudgetSeniors team Team 5 months ago Don't stop paying and don't sign the reduction form yet. A 35% jump on a policy you've held for 13 years is a decision you can make calmly, but only after you've got every option priced in writing and you've looked at what your own policy says about premium increases. This is general information, not insurance or financial advice, and your policy's wording controls.
Start with the numbers in the scenario. A premium of $3,100 going up 35% becomes $4,185, which is $1,085 more a year, or about $90 a month. If you kept paying that for ten more years and nothing else rose, you'd pay roughly $41,850. Insurers often come back for more than one increase, so treat that as a floor, not a forecast. Washington State's insurance commissioner says plainly that early policies were underpriced, that insurers didn't expect to pay out so much in claims, and that they have to change premiums to keep enough money on hand to pay claims. That isn't comforting, but it tells you the pressure that caused this letter hasn't gone away.
What the policy is worth today
The money you already paid is gone. Whether to keep going depends only on what the policy will pay compared with what future premiums cost.
AdvertisementSay your $200-a-day benefit has grown at 3% compounded for 13 years. That's about $294 a day now ($200 times 1.03 to the 13th power). Over a four-year benefit period, the pool would be roughly $429,000 if the pool grows the same way. Now compare it with the care it would meet. CareScout's 2025 cost-of-care survey puts the national median for a private nursing home room at $355 a day and a semi-private room at $315. Against $355, a $294 benefit leaves a gap of about $61 a day, around $22,000 a year, for you to cover. For care at home, the same survey's national median for a non-medical caregiver is $35 an hour, so $294 a day buys about eight hours of help.
So the policy isn't useless, and it isn't a full shield either. It's a large partial payment toward a bill that Medicare won't touch. Medicare.gov states that Medicare doesn't pay for long-term care and that you pay all costs for non-covered services, including most long-term care. The alternatives to your policy are your savings, family, or Medicaid if you qualify under your state's rules.
The long term care insurance cost of each choice
Insurance regulators describe the usual ways to bring a premium down. Washington's commissioner lists these:
- Lower the daily benefit.
- Shorten the benefit period, for example two years instead of five.
- Lengthen the elimination period, the wait before benefits begin.
- Reduce the optional inflation protection.
- Use the contingent nonforfeiture option, which lets you stop paying and keep some coverage.
Each one trades a bit of future protection for a lower bill, and they aren't equal. Shortening the benefit period can hurt least if you have savings to carry a very long claim yourself. A longer elimination period, say 90 days to 180, means you'd cover a few more months yourself. Reducing the inflation growth going forward while keeping what you've already accumulated is the option many people like, because your benefit stays at today's level instead of shrinking. Cutting the daily benefit hits hardest, because you're already below the cost of a nursing home bed in most places.
AdvertisementDon't guess which is cheapest. Call the insurer and ask for every available option, with the new annual premium and the new daily benefit and total pool for each, in writing. Then lay them side by side. A sheet with four rows (pay the increase, trim inflation, shorten the benefit period, trim the daily benefit) makes the choice obvious far more often than people expect.
Contingent nonforfeiture: the safety net people miss
Many policies include a feature that applies only when the cumulative premium increase since you bought the policy crosses a threshold, usually a percentage of the original premium that depends on your age at purchase. If you qualify, you can stop paying and keep a paid-up benefit, which Washington's commissioner describes as generally equal to the premiums you've paid minus any claims already paid out. State rate-increase disclosure forms, an older Kentucky sample for one, tie the trigger to a cumulative percentage over the original premium, not just this year's increase, so a 35% jump on top of earlier increases may matter more than it looks.
The catch is that the leftover benefit can be small. A policy where you've paid about $40,000 over the years could leave you with a paid-up pool in that neighborhood, far below the $429,000 you'd have by continuing. It beats lapsing and getting nothing, though, which is why you shouldn't just stop paying. Ask your insurer in writing whether your policy has this feature, whether you've reached the trigger, and what the resulting pool would be. Thresholds vary by state and policy, so rely on your policy and your state insurance department, not on a general rule.
When dropping the policy can be reasonable
Letting a policy go with no paid-up benefit is the last choice, not the first. It makes sense in a few situations. If the premium is squeezing food, medicine and utilities, the policy is hurting you now to help a future that may not come. If you have enough savings to pay for years of care without strain, you may be self-insured already. If your assets are low enough that Medicaid would likely cover long-term care, a policy with a rising premium may add little, though Medicaid rules differ by state and have look-back periods, so talk to a free source of legal help before assuming anything.
Replacing the policy with a new one at 68 is often not the answer. The American Association for Long-Term Care Insurance's 2025 price survey, for a $165,000 starting pool growing at 3%, found a couple both age 65 paying from $7,137 to $12,250 a year depending on which of three big insurers they chose. A single woman of 65 paid $5,290 for the same design. Your existing policy at $4,185 is still cheaper than starting over, and health changes can make you uninsurable.
Taxes and who to call
Part of your premium may count as a medical expense if you itemize. The IRS lets you include qualified long-term care premiums up to an age-based limit: for the 2025 tax year it was $4,810 for ages 61 to 70 and $6,020 for 71 and over, per person. You can deduct only the part of total medical expenses above 7.5% of adjusted gross income, so many people with modest income get no benefit. The limits change yearly, so check the current IRS publication on medical expenses.
For help, call your state insurance department's consumer line (the National Association of Insurance Commissioners lists each state) and ask for a long-term care rate increase specialist. Your local Area Agency on Aging, which the Eldercare Locator at 1-800-677-1116 can find, may offer free counseling, and your State Health Insurance Assistance Program may help with Medicare side questions. Be careful with anyone who wants an upfront fee to review or "rescue" your policy; the options above come from the insurer and the regulator at no charge.
Before deciding, collect three things: the premium notice, your original policy schedule showing the daily benefit and inflation rider, and the priced options. Then ask yourself one plain question: if you needed care at 80, would you rather hold a smaller benefit you can afford to keep, or a bigger one you might have to abandon in two years?
Key sources: Washington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner; CareScout; American Association for Long-Term Care Insurance; Medicare.gov