Skip to content
๐Ÿฉบ Medicare & health costs

How much does Medigap Plan G cost at 70, and why does the premium go up every year?

Asked by BudgetSeniors team ยท 2 weeks ago

Say you bought a Medigap Plan G at 65 for about $250 a month and were told it was a good price. Now at 72 your renewal notice shows a much higher premium, and your insurer says it is a normal rate adjustment. You want to know what Plan G usually costs at different ages, what the difference is between attained-age, issue-age and community rating, whether a cheaper policy from another insurer gives the same coverage, and what you can do if you cannot afford the increase. This is about Medigap in the United States.

1 reply

  1. BudgetSeniors team Team 2 weeks ago

    Plan G benefits are the same no matter who sells it, so when the premium climbs at your birthday, the only thing that changed is the price. That makes Plan G one of the few insurance products where you can shop with confidence, and one where the way the insurer rates by age tells you most of what you'll pay in ten years. This answer is about Medigap in the United States, and it uses real filed rates from one state, so read the numbers as an example of the pattern, not a quote.

    What the filed rates look like by age

    Maryland's Insurance Administration publishes a rate guide listing the monthly premiums each insurer has on file. The edition we read is for rates as of January 1, 2027, and covers ages 65, 70, 75, 80 and 85. We pulled out every Plan G rate row, 81 in all (different insurers, with male and female and preferred and standard classes), and looked at the spread at each age:

    • Age 65: from $177 to $494 a month, with a median of $269.
    • Age 70: from $177 to $545, median $296.
    • Age 75: from $214 to $652, median $355.
    • Age 80: from $268 to $753, median $413.
    • Age 85: from $314 to $838, median $491.
    Advertisement

    Two things jump out. The same coverage can cost more than twice as much from one insurer as from another at the same age. And the median climbs about 82 percent from 65 to 85. Different states, with different rating rules, will have different numbers, so use these only to see the shape.

    Why the premium keeps going up

    Medicare.gov says each insurer decides how to set its prices, and that premium amounts typically increase each year. The Maryland guide lays out the three methods:

    • Attained age. The premium is based on your age at your last policy anniversary and steps up on a schedule, for example every year or every five years. These increases are on top of any increase from inflation, benefit changes or rising medical costs.
    • Issue age. The premium is based on your age when you bought the policy. It can still go up with medical costs or benefit changes, but not because you got older.
    • Community rated. The premium doesn't depend on your age at all, and changes only from benefit changes or overall adjustments.

    Here is what attained-age pricing looks like for one Maryland carrier in the guide, American Benefit Life Insurance Company, for a male on its preferred rate. Plan G is $253 at 65, $260 at 70, $317 at 75, $385 at 80 and $500 at 85. That's a rise of nearly 98 percent from 65 to 85. Notice the pattern: the jump from 70 to 75 is about 22 percent, bigger than the five years before. For the same carrier and class, Plan N goes from $185 at 65 to $407 at 85.

    On top of age, each insurer's overall rate level changes with claims experience. And Plan G doesn't cover the Part B deductible, so when that deductible rises, as it does from $283 in 2026 to $292 in 2027, you pay the difference yourself. Medigap also doesn't cover your Part B premium, which is $209.40 a month in 2027, or your Part D plan.

    Because attained-age policies start low, the first quote at 65 can look like a bargain. Take the Maryland carrier above: $253 a month at 65 sounds fine, but the same filing shows $385 by 80. A policy rated by issue age or community rated can start higher but doesn't step up for age, but its base rate can still rise as claims rise. Which one costs less over twenty years depends on how fast each insurer's base rates climb, and nobody can know that at 65. The point isn't that one method always wins. It's that the quote at 65 alone doesn't tell you the cost at 80.

    Advertisement

    Ask each insurer three questions: Is this rated by attained age, issue age or community rating? What is the schedule of increases by age? What was the average rate increase on this plan over the past five years? In Maryland, insurers file their rates with the state, and a state insurance department can often tell you how a particular plan's rates have moved.

    How to bring the cost down

    • Compare the same letter. Medicare.gov says the price is the only difference between Plan G policies from different companies. Get quotes from several insurers for Plan G at your exact age and ZIP code. Ask about discounts. Medicare.gov lists discounts for women, non-smokers, married people, paying yearly, paying by automatic transfer, and multiple policies. In the Maryland guide, some carriers also list a household discount, such as 7 or 10 percent.
    • Look at high-deductible Plan G. In states where it is sold, you pay the first $2,950 of Medicare-covered costs in 2026 ($3,050 in 2027) before the policy pays anything, and then it pays 100 percent for the rest of the year. The premium is lower, but you're taking a risk. Only consider it if you could pay a $3,050 bill from savings in a bad year. The high-deductible policy doesn't cover the Part B deductible either.
    • Consider Plan N. Plan N costs less than Plan G in the rate guide, but you pay up to $20 for some office visits, up to $50 for an emergency room visit that doesn't lead to admission, and costs above Medicare's approved amount if your doctor charges more. For the Maryland carrier above, switching from G to N at 70 would save $58 a month, or $696 a year, in exchange for those copays. If you rarely see doctors, that can be a good trade. If you see specialists often, it can cost more than it saves.
    • Don't drop to save money you can't replace. Medigap can generally be renewed as long as you pay, but if you drop it and later want to return, you may face medical underwriting. Medicare.gov warns that once your six-month open enrollment period ends, a policy may be unavailable to you or cost more.

    Can you switch insurers?

    Often yes, but it depends on the state and your health. In many states, switching to a new insurer after your open enrollment means answering health questions. Maryland has a rule that helps: policyholders get a yearly 30-day window after their birthday to move to a policy of equal or lesser value without underwriting, and insurers must send a notice 30 to 60 days beforehand. That's the Maryland rule, not a national one, so ask your State Health Insurance Assistance Program whether your state has something like it. SHIP help is free, and you can reach your local office by calling 1-800-MEDICARE.

    If you've been in good health and your premium jumped by a lot, a call to your state insurance department is also worth it. They can tell you if the increase was approved and whether other insurers are cheaper for your age.

    If Plan G is eating too much of your Social Security, don't let the policy lapse without checking your other options. Medicare Savings Programs, Extra Help and Medicaid can lower your costs, and your SHIP counselor can screen you for them at no charge. Be wary of anyone who calls or emails offering a cheaper "Medicare supplement" in exchange for your Medicare number, or who charges an upfront fee for help that SHIP gives for free. If that happens, hang up and file a complaint through the FTC's ReportFraud service. AARP's fraud helpline, 877-908-3360, will also listen.

    This is general information, not insurance or financial advice. The rate figures above are one state's filed rates, and your own premium depends on your state, your age, your insurer and in some states your health.

    Key sources: Maryland Insurance Administration; Medicare.gov

Add your reply

Your email is never shown. Be kind โ€” someone may be worried about money. Never post account, Social Security or Medicare numbers.