Skip to content
๐Ÿฉบ Medicare & health costs

Is the Medicare Advantage out-of-pocket maximum really the most I could pay in a year?

Asked by BudgetSeniors team ยท 2 weeks ago

Say you are 70 and weighing a $0-premium Medicare Advantage plan with a listed maximum out-of-pocket of about $5,000 against Original Medicare with a Medigap Plan G that runs close to $300 a month. The plan looks cheaper, yet the Medigap salesperson says the cap is not a true ceiling. You want to know what the out-of-pocket maximum counts and leaves out, how the 2027 limits compare, what a healthy year and a very sick year would cost each way, and why switching later can be harder. This is about the United States.

See alsoMedicare Advantage vs Medigap on a fixed income: can I switch back later if I need to?

1 reply

  1. BudgetSeniors team Team 2 weeks ago

    The out-of-pocket maximum is the most you can owe for covered medical care in a year, not the most you can spend on Medicare altogether, and that gap is where people get surprised. For 2027, a Medicare Advantage plan's in-network limit can be as high as $9,850 (the 2027 federal ceiling as reported by the National Council on Aging), and the Part B premium, the plan premium and your drug costs sit outside it. This answer is about the United States. We ran the numbers for a healthy year and a very sick year, using the 2027 amounts, to see where Original Medicare with a Medigap Plan G comes out ahead and where it doesn't.

    What the limit is, and what it leaves out

    Original Medicare has no yearly cap on what you pay, as Medicare.gov states. Medicare Advantage is different: each plan has a yearly limit, and once you reach it the plan pays 100 percent of covered services for the rest of the calendar year. KFF reports that in 2026 the ceiling is $9,250 for in-network care and $13,900 for in-network and out-of-network care combined. The National Council on Aging reports that for 2027 the in-network ceiling rises to $9,850. Plans may set lower limits, and many do. KFF found the average in 2026 was $5,421 in-network. About one in ten Medicare Advantage enrollees was in a plan at the $9,250 maximum, and nearly one in five faced an in-network limit above $7,000.

    Advertisement

    Two limits to keep in mind. First, the cap covers medical benefits, not your prescription drugs. Part D has its own cap, $2,100 in 2026 and $2,400 in 2027, whichever kind of plan you have. Second, premiums aren't part of it. You must keep paying the Part B premium, $209.40 a month in 2027, and any premium your plan charges.

    A year-by-year comparison with real numbers

    Say you're 70 and choose between Original Medicare with a Plan G Medigap policy and a $0-premium Medicare Advantage plan. Plan premiums vary by state, so for Plan G we used the median of the rates filed with the Maryland Insurance Administration for age 70 as of January 1, 2027, which is $296 a month. That is one state's filings, so it's only a stand-in. Plug in a quote for your own ZIP code instead.

    Original Medicare with Plan G, 2027:

    • Part B premium: $209.40 times 12 is $2,512.80.
    • Plan G premium: $296 times 12 is $3,552.
    • Part B deductible, which Plan G doesn't pay: $292.
    • Total in a healthy year or a hospital year: about $6,357, because Plan G pays the rest of the Medicare-approved costs, including the $1,776 Part A hospital deductible. You still pay for drugs separately in either option.

    Medicare Advantage with a $0 premium:

    • Part B premium: $2,512.80.
    • In a healthy year, say $400 in copays: about $2,913.
    • In a very sick year, with the plan at the average limit of $5,421: about $7,934.
    • In a very sick year, at the 2027 maximum of $9,850: about $12,363.

    So the healthy year favors Medicare Advantage by about $3,400, and the sickest year favors Plan G by about $6,000 if your plan is at the ceiling. The break-even point is simple. Plan G costs $3,844 a year more than the Advantage plan before you use any care ($3,552 in premiums plus the $292 deductible). If you expect to pay less than $3,844 in Advantage copays and coinsurance, the Advantage plan comes out ahead. If you have a heart problem, cancer, or repeated hospital stays, it's more likely to be the other way around.

    Advertisement

    These are sums, not predictions. A plan can have a premium above zero, and a plan with a lower limit than the maximum changes the sick-year number.

    What the limit doesn't tell you

    A cap on cost is only useful if the care is covered and you can get to it. Medicare Advantage plans use networks, and many require approval before certain services. KFF's data show that PPO plans have a separate, higher combined limit for in-network and out-of-network care, and that HMOs average a lower in-network limit ($4,636 in 2026 compared with $6,592 for PPOs). A lower limit is not automatically better if the network is narrow. Before you pick, check that your own doctors, your hospital, and your specialist are in the network, and ask how the plan handles prior approval.

    Also look at the cost structure underneath the cap. A plan with a low cap but a $350 a day hospital copay for six days, for example, can leave you spending a lot before reaching the limit. Read the "Evidence of Coverage" and the Summary of Benefits, and look at what you'd pay for the services you use most, such as specialist visits, imaging, physical therapy and chemotherapy.

    The decision that is hard to undo

    Medicare.gov explains that you get a one-time six-month Medigap open enrollment period starting the first month you have Part B and are 65 or older, during which no insurer can turn you down for health reasons. Once that window closes, insurers in most states can ask health questions, and some may turn you down or charge more. That matters because many people choose a cheap Advantage plan at 65 and later want out after a diagnosis. If you drop Medigap to join Advantage for the first time, you get a 12-month trial right to go back, if the same insurer still sells it. After that, rules depend on your state. Some states add their own switching rights, and your State Health Insurance Assistance Program, or SHIP, can tell you what applies to you.

    How to check your own numbers

    • Go to Medicare.gov and use the plan finder with your ZIP code and your medications. For each Advantage plan, find the "maximum out-of-pocket" line and then the copays for hospital stays and specialists.
    • Ask a Medigap insurer, or your state insurance department, for Plan G quotes at your age, and ask whether the rate is attained-age, issue-age or community-rated.
    • Call your State Health Insurance Assistance Program for free, unbiased help. Search "SHIP" with your state name, or call 1-800-MEDICARE and ask for the local number.
    • During the Medicare Open Enrollment, the fall period for changing coverage for the next year, compare your plan's new limit. It can change every year, and the 2027 ceiling went up.

    If you are low-income, the Medicare Savings Programs or Extra Help may pay some of the costs mentioned above, and some states give extra protection through Medicaid. Don't let an agent or a phone caller rush you. Anyone who calls you unprompted to push a plan change, asks for your Medicare number to "verify" something, or promises free benefits that need your bank details should be hung up on. Report it through the FTC's ReportFraud service, and know that AARP's Fraud Watch line (877-908-3360) answers questions about suspicious plan offers.

    This is general information, not financial or medical advice. Plan rules, limits and prices change each year, and what suits someone with one chronic condition may not suit you.

    Key sources: Medicare.gov; KFF; National Council on Aging; Maryland Insurance Administration

Add your reply

Your email is never shown. Be kind โ€” someone may be worried about money. Never post account, Social Security or Medicare numbers.