Skip to content
๐Ÿ“’ Budgeting & saving

Is an annuity a good idea at 67 when an agent wants $100,000 of my savings?

Asked by BudgetSeniors team ยท 4 months ago

Say you’re 67, retired, with about $140,000 in savings and Social Security as your main income. An insurance agent says you need an annuity and suggests putting $100,000 into a fixed indexed annuity that locks the money up for seven years. The agent mentions guaranteed income and no market losses, but the paperwork is thick and there’s pressure to decide this week. You don’t know what fees, surrender charges or limits are buried in the contract. Before signing anything, what should you ask, what are the real costs of locking money away, and who can give a second opinion that isn’t paid commission?

1 reply

  1. BudgetSeniors team Team 4 months ago

    If a salesperson says you need an annuity, the honest first answer is: maybe, but not today, and not at that desk. Whether an annuity is a good idea depends on the exact kind, how long your money would be locked up, what it costs you in ways you can't see on a quote, and whether you'd have been fine without it. Take the paperwork home, don't sign anything that day, and use the questions below before you decide.

    First, which annuity is it?

    "Annuity" is a family of products, not one thing. The SEC's investor education site sorts the deferred kinds, in order of rising risk, into four types.

    • Fixed annuity: the insurer guarantees a minimum interest rate. The company sets the rate, and only the minimum is promised.
    • Fixed indexed annuity: interest is based partly on how an index, such as the S&P 500, performs over a set term. You don't know the rate ahead of time, but it's guaranteed never to fall below zero.
    • Registered index-linked annuity (RILA): also tied to an index, but you can lose money.
    • Variable annuity: your money goes into mutual funds, and losses can be unlimited.

    There's also the immediate kind, where you hand over a lump sum and the income starts within about a year. When we read the SEC's page, that was the clearest line between "buy income now" and "park money and hope it grows."

    Advertisement

    Ask the agent to name the type out loud, in those words. If the answer is vague, that tells you something.

    Many fixed, fixed indexed and index-linked annuities charge no explicit yearly fee. That sounds good until you read the next part of the SEC's explanation: the cost shows up as limits on what you earn. The SEC's example is an insurer that earns 4% on your money and credits you 3%. In an indexed annuity, caps on gains do the same job.

    Variable annuities are the opposite. They have explicit fees. The SEC gives this example: a 1.25% base contract fee on a $300,000 contract is $3,750 a year, and that's before the fees on the underlying funds and any optional rider.

    So when someone says "no fees," your next sentence is: "Then show me the cap, the participation rate and any other limit on what I can earn, in writing."

    The lock-up: surrender charges

    Most deferred annuities charge you if you pull money out early. The SEC calls this a surrender charge and says it usually shrinks over time. Say you put in $100,000 and the charge starts at 7% and drops by one point a year; your contract's schedule will differ. Need $20,000 in year two for a roof or a hospital bill and the charge is 6%, so about $1,200 comes off the top, on money you thought was yours. That's before any taxes.

    Taxes are the second bite. The SEC notes that a withdrawal may be taxable, and if you take money out before age 59ยฝ you may owe a 10% federal tax penalty on top. Some contracts also have value adjustments that can lower what you get back when you leave early, in addition to the surrender charge.

    For a reader on a fixed income, the question isn't "what will it earn?" It's "what happens if I need this money in year three?"

    Questions that tell you whether it's a good idea

    The SEC's own checklist is a fair place to start. Put these to the agent and write down the answers.

    • What type of annuity is this, and why does it fit my goals better than the alternatives?
    • What are all the fees, including ones hidden in caps or crediting limits?
    • How many years must I keep it to avoid a surrender charge, and what's the charge each year?
    • Can I take out some money each year without a charge? How much?
    • What happens to my beneficiary if I die?
    • What does each rider cost, and under what conditions does it actually pay?
    • How financially strong is the insurance company? The SEC points out that your annuity is only as good as the insurer's ability to pay.
    • How are you paid if I buy this?
    Advertisement

    That last one is fair to ask. The SEC says part of the base fee can go toward the commission of the person who sold it. A salesperson who earns more for one contract than another has a reason to push, even a kind one.

    Three situations deserve extra caution.

    • "Exchange your old annuity for this better one." The SEC warns that some professionals have a financial incentive to suggest this. An exchange can mean a surrender charge to leave the old contract and a brand new surrender period on the new one.
    • An annuity inside an IRA or 401(k). The SEC says you get no extra tax deferral there, since the account is already tax-deferred. Ask what the annuity adds that's worth paying for.
    • Money you may need soon. The SEC states that annuities suit people with a long time horizon. If a medical bill, home repair or help for a family member could plausibly land in the next several years, a locked-up contract is a poor fit.

    An annuity isn't a scam by itself. For someone who wants a guaranteed paycheck for life and has other money set aside for emergencies, an immediate annuity or a plain fixed annuity can be reasonable. The SEC lists guaranteed income as one of the reasons people buy them. The trouble starts when a complicated product is sold as the only answer, or when it uses most of your savings.

    A rough rule we'd apply: if buying it would leave you without enough ready cash to cover a year of surprises, it's too much of your money. Never borrow to buy one, and never cash out other safe savings in a rush to hit a deadline the salesperson gave you.

    Your safety net: the free look

    State law generally gives you a window, usually 10 to 30 days after you receive the contract, to change your mind and return it. The SEC calls this the "free look" period. The contract should say how long yours is and how to return it. Ask for the exact number of days before you sign, and put a reminder on your calendar.

    Where to take the paperwork

    Before you sign, get a second opinion from someone who doesn't get paid if you buy.

    • Your state insurance department handles complaints about fixed and fixed indexed annuities, since the SEC notes those are insurance products regulated by the state.
    • For a registered product like a variable annuity or RILA, the SEC accepts complaints, and its Check Out Your Investment Professional search tool shows whether the person selling is registered and whether they have a disciplinary history.
    • Your Area Agency on Aging can point you to free counseling. The Eldercare Locator is 1-800-677-1116.
    • A fee-only financial planner, who charges a flat fee instead of a commission, can read the contract with you. Ask them to say in writing how they're paid.

    You can use a line like this: "I don't sign on the first visit. Please leave me the full contract, the illustration and the surrender schedule, and I'll call you if I have questions." A real professional will agree. If the answer is "this rate expires today," treat that as a reason to walk away, not to hurry.

    This is general information, not financial or tax advice. Look at your own full picture, ideally with a second set of eyes, before moving a large chunk of savings into any contract you can't easily undo.

    Key sources: SEC Office of Investor Education (Investor.gov); State insurance regulators (as described by the SEC)

Add your reply

Your email is never shown. Be kind โ€” someone may be worried about money. Never post account, Social Security or Medicare numbers.