Retired this year but Medicare still charges an IRMAA surcharge: how do I file an IRMAA appeal?
Say you earned about $140,000 in 2025, retired in 2026, and now live on a pension and Social Security totaling roughly $60,000. Medicare is charging an income-related surcharge for 2027 based on that old income, adding about $84 a month to the Part B premium. You want to know how to appeal an IRMAA decision, whether retirement counts as a reason, what proof Social Security wants, which tax year it will use, and what the deadlines are.
1 reply
-
๐ก BudgetSeniors team Team 4 hours ago If you stopped working or cut back and your income is now far below what you earned two years ago, you can ask Social Security to base your Medicare surcharge on your lower, more recent income. For this kind of IRMAA appeal, the usual route isn't a formal appeal at all. It's a request for a "new initial determination" based on a life-changing event, and retiring qualifies. You'll need proof of the event and your income for the more recent year.
Why Medicare is looking at old income
IRMAA stands for income-related monthly adjustment amount, a surcharge added to the Part B premium for people with higher incomes. Social Security, not Medicare, calculates it, using figures it gets from the IRS. The rule is that SSA uses your modified adjusted gross income from the tax return two years before the premium year. For a 2027 premium, that's your 2025 return. If the IRS can't supply that year yet, SSA uses the year before it for the time being.
Modified adjusted gross income is your adjusted gross income plus certain tax-exempt items, including tax-exempt interest. Wages in your last year at work, a retirement payout, a Roth conversion and capital gains all go into it.
AdvertisementWhat the 2027 numbers look like
The 2027 amounts come from a CMS notice in the Federal Register dated November 19, 2026, which sets the standard Part B premium at $209.40. For a single filer, the surcharges are:
- $112,000 or less: no surcharge, $209.40.
- Over $112,000 up to $141,000: adds $83.70, for $293.10.
- Over $141,000 up to $177,000: adds $209.40, for $418.80.
- Over $177,000 up to $212,000: adds $335.00, for $544.40.
- Over $212,000 and under $500,000: adds $460.60, for $670.00.
- $500,000 or more: adds $502.40, for $711.80.
For joint filers, the dividing lines are $224,000, $282,000, $354,000, $424,000 and $750,000. The 2026 starting points were $109,000 for a single filer and $218,000 for joint filers.
Here's an example. Say your 2025 income was $140,000 because you worked most of the year, and you retired late in 2025 or in 2026. That puts you in the second bracket, so you'd pay $293.10 a month in 2027, which is $1,004.40 a year more than the standard premium. If your income has dropped to $60,000, you'd owe no surcharge. A bracket line matters down to the dollar, so even a small income drop can change your bracket.
What counts as a life-changing event
The regulations list the events SSA accepts:
- Your spouse dies.
- You marry.
- Your marriage ends in divorce or annulment.
- You or your spouse stop working or reduce hours.
- You or your spouse lose income-producing property, when the loss isn't your choice and isn't ordinary investment risk. Examples are a disaster, crop or livestock loss, arson, or a theft or fraud by a third party.
- A scheduled end, termination or reorganization of an employer's pension plan.
- A settlement from an employer because of a closure, bankruptcy or reorganization.
Events that only raise your expenses don't count, and neither does investment loss from ordinary risk. A one-time event that isn't on the list, like selling a house or stock, converting an IRA to a Roth or taking a big withdrawal, doesn't qualify on its own. If a big sale spiked the income SSA is using, you may need another route, such as an amended return if it was reported incorrectly.
AdvertisementThe event also has to cause a significant reduction in your income, which the regulation defines as one that lowers your percentage or removes the surcharge. In plain terms, it has to move you down at least one bracket.
How to ask, step by step
- Call SSA at 1-800-772-1213 or go to your local office and say you want to request a new initial determination for IRMAA because of a life-changing event. SSA's operating manual tells staff to set up an appointment with the field office. The optional form is the SSA-44, Medicare Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount, Life-Changing Event. You can use the form but you don't have to.
- Provide proof of the event. For stopping work or cutting hours, the regulations say acceptable documents include a signed statement from your employer, proof of a business transfer, or your own signed statement under penalty of perjury describing your work separation or reduced hours. For a death, marriage or divorce, SSA wants proof of the event if it doesn't already have it, such as a certified divorce decree.
- Give SSA the more recent year's income. If you've filed that year's return, SSA asks for your copy. If you haven't, the manual says SSA needs a statement estimating your income. You may also give an estimate for the following year. If you don't, SSA uses the first year's estimate for the next year, too.
- Ask for the decision to cover the right years. Keep a note of the date of the call and who you talked to.
The request has to meet SSA's timing rules. The decision generally takes effect in January of the year you ask, or your first month of Part B if it came later. An event in the last three months of a year can be applied to that year if you ask by March 31 of the next year. For an event in the past, you can ask for the year it occurred or later, but the decision can't reach back before the event. If you miss a deadline, SSA can still consider good cause for lateness.
If the answer is no, or you disagree
A reconsideration is the formal appeal. You have 60 days from receiving the notice to request it in writing, and SSA can extend that with good cause. The form is the SSA-561. The manual says you can file a request for a new initial determination and a reconsideration at the same time, and SSA must accept an appeal if you want one. A predetermination notice, which is a notice of planned action, doesn't carry appeal rights.
Other reasons to request a new decision: you filed an amended return for the year SSA used, or the IRS information SSA has is wrong. If the IRS data is wrong, SSA says to contact the IRS at 1-800-829-1040 to get it corrected first, then come back with the correction.
- A similar surcharge applies to Medicare drug coverage for people above the thresholds, and SSA's new decision can cover it too.
- People who pay a surcharge don't get the hold-harmless protection that limits a premium increase to the size of the Social Security raise.
- A decision for one spouse doesn't automatically carry over to the other. If the event affects both of you, each should contact SSA.
- Give SSA honest estimates, since it can compare them later with your tax return.
Your State Health Insurance Assistance Program counselors can help with Medicare questions at no cost, and your local Area Agency on Aging can direct you to one; 1-800-677-1116 (the Eldercare Locator) will give you its number. You can also call 1-800-MEDICARE at 1-800-633-4227. Don't pay a company to file this request. The forms are free, and SSA staff can help you complete them.
That is general information, not tax or legal advice. SSA decides each case on your records and evidence.
Key sources: Social Security Administration (federal regulations and Program Operations Manual); Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services